How to make premium looking olive oil packaging

TL;DR

Monica analyzes a minimalist olive oil label and argues for stronger brand storytelling and a refined finish. She notes issues like dual labeling and calendar-like information clutter, and suggests matte finishes, cleaner typography, and subtle metallic accents to elevate shelf presence. The critique emphasizes aligning design with perceived quality without abandoning the Italian identity.

Transcript

all right so this is part two the package design critique let's get back into it all right now it's time to check out what Monica has done Monica what do you have for us here any foods aren't really a big deal so really I had chosen a different quite sophisticated packaging but after playing for a couple days with it I realized that it may not actu... Read More

Key Insights

• Monica prioritizes minimalistic design to enhance shelf presence over heavy imagery.
• The logo and colors should stay consistent, but packaging can use texture and finish to feel premium.
• Repetitive caloric and regulatory data on multiple label areas hurts clarity and brand cohesion.
• Two label surfaces should be harmonized through material contrast rather than redundancy.
• A refined matte label with a selective gloss accent can elevate perceived value.
• Typography and engraving elements can communicate quality without relying on clichés.
• Avoid clichéd Italy imagery like crude boot vectors; seek subtler cultural storytelling.
• Print production choices, like edge craft and paper fibers, can convey handmade authenticity.
• More videos from this channel:
  • How to Get Clients to State Their Real Budget
  • How to give first to earn more money and clients
  • How to Prevent Late Client Revisions Effectively
• More from this channel: The Futur

Questions & Answers

Q: What design approach does Monica favor for the olive oil package critique

Monica favors a minimal, straight to the point design that emphasizes shelf presence through clean typography, restrained color use, and material choices. She argues this approach makes the product look premium without resorting to heavy imagery, and she suggests practical changes like reducing label duplication and exploring upscale finishes.

Q: Why does the two label setup bother the designer in the critique

The two labels create visual clutter and messaging redundancy, with caloric values appearing more than once and other government information repeated across surfaces. Monica believes a single, carefully designed main label backed by a more discreet secondary data area would improve clarity, aesthetic appeal, and perceived quality.

Q: What finish options are proposed to enhance perceived value

The designer proposes using a matte label with a possible glossy accent to add a premium feel. Texture and finish are seen as key tools to communicate higher quality, so subtle contrasts and material choice are recommended to elevate the product without changing its logo or core colors.

Q: What role does typography play in the critique

Typography is viewed as a critical element that can elevate the product when used with a clean serif or refined sans, paired with careful spacing and hierarchy. The critique emphasizes avoiding overbearing or cliché imagery and instead relying on type to convey elegance and authenticity.

Q: How should imagery be treated according to the critique

Imagery should be restrained and avoid clichés like crude boot illustrations. The critique argues for more conceptual storytelling through typography, engraving motifs, and refined material textures that hint at Italian heritage without shouting it, enabling a premium feel that is still authentic.

Q: What is suggested to make the packaging feel handmade or artisanal

Suggestions include using edge effects that mimic torn or fiber-rich paper, stamps or seals to imply import status, and multiple paper textures. These tactile cues give a sense of craft and story while differentiating the product on shelves.

Q: What is the main objective of this packaging review episode

The main objective is to demonstrate how packaging design can alter perceived value for a commodity by improving shelf presence, appeal, and feature highlighting, while staying true to brand constraints and the product’s origin. The critique focuses on practical changes rather than complete brand overhauls.

Q: How does the episode address balance between Italian identity and premium design

The episode suggests conveying Italian identity through tasteful, non clichéd cues such as refined typography and subtle Italian-inspired elements, rather than obvious country imagery. The aim is to maintain authenticity while achieving a sophisticated, premium look that appeals to higher-end consumers.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• Monica critiques the sauce packaging for being minimal yet connected to Italian cues, suggesting adjustments to improve premium perception without losing brand identity. She highlights label hierarchy, material choices, and the balance between country imagery and modern print techniques. The result should feel premium yet authentic.

• The episode reviews how a packaging redesign can shift perceived value by refining typography, eliminating redundant data, and using tactile finishes. Emphasis is placed on creating a story through materials, texture, and careful color use while maintaining legibility and compliance with labeling rules.

• The overall goal is to teach how to elevate a commodity like olive oil through packaging that commands higher-end shelf presence while staying true to the product’s origins and regulatory constraints.