Can Trees Like Elden Ring's Erdtree Exist in Reality?

TL;DR

Real-world tree height is limited by atmospheric pressure and gravity, meaning the 500-meter Erd Tree from Elden Ring is highly unlikely to exist. While trees can exceed 10 meters due to the cohesion tension theory, achieving heights comparable to the Erd Tree would require unique planetary conditions not currently known in science.

Transcript

the falling leaves tell a story of a tarnished who became obsessed with the idea of big glowy trees based on everything that is known about physics biology and definitely not magic he asked how big can a tree actually get can a tannish use this question to learn something special about the lands between can one even imagine not having any maidens k... Read More

Key Insights

• 💦 The growth of trees is limited by factors such as atmospheric pressure, gravity, and the ability of water to be pulled up through xylem.
• 🤒 The cohesion tension theory explains how trees surpass the 10-meter height limit by actively pulling water through xylem tubes.
• 🤒 The Erd Tree in Elden Ring, standing at 500 meters tall, is unlikely to be found in reality based on our current knowledge of exoplanets.
• 👨‍🔬 Research on the maximum height of trees on other planets is limited, and calculations involve making educated guesses based on available data.
• 🌲 The possibility of trees taller than the theoretical maximum height is dependent on variables like gravity and atmospheric pressure in different environments.
• 👻 Conditions in fictitious worlds like Elden Ring may allow for trees taller than what can be found on Earth.
• 🌲 Further scientific exploration and understanding of exoplanets and their environments is necessary to determine the maximum height of trees in the universe.

Questions & Answers

Q: How do trees surpass the 10-meter height limit imposed by atmospheric pressure?

Trees are able to exceed the limit through the cohesion tension theory. Water is pulled up through xylem tubes, taking advantage of the adhesive and cohesive forces between water molecules.

Q: Can trees grow as tall as the Erd Tree in Elden Ring, which is 500 meters tall?

Based on current knowledge of exoplanets and their gravity, it is unlikely to find trees as tall as the Erd Tree in reality. The height of trees is influenced by factors such as atmospheric pressure and the mass and radius of the planet they grow on.

Q: Are there any scientific studies or research on the maximum height of trees on other planets?

Scientist and author Dr. David S. Stevenson has explored the relationship between pressure, weight, and gravity to estimate the maximum tree height on exoplanets. However, research on this topic is limited, and the calculations involve making educated guesses based on available data.

Q: Is it possible to have trees taller than the theoretical maximum height determined by Earth's gravity?

Trees taller than the theoretical maximum height can be possible if the lands between, like in Elden Ring, have significantly different variables such as gravity and atmospheric pressure. However, this may require conditions and environments that go beyond our current understanding of the natural world.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• In Elden Ring, the Erd Tree, which stands at 500 meters tall, is an impressive visual element and a key part of the game.

• The growth of trees is limited by factors such as atmospheric pressure, gravity, and the ability of water to be pulled up through xylem.

• The cohesion tension theory explains that water is actively pulled up by negative pressure, allowing trees to exceed the 10-meter limit determined by atmospheric pressure.