How to Fix an Offer That Is Not Converting

TL;DR

Improve a weak offer by making the customer’s desired outcome faster, less risky, or easier to achieve, then charge a premium that reflects the added value. To attract a broader audience, replace generic quote requests with a desirable lead magnet and build a conversion process that turns those leads into customers over a longer time horizon.

Transcript

Many people still have terrible offers and or terrible lead magnets. So, I'm going to cover kind of like the common troubleshooting that I go into with people who have bad offers, bad lead magnets, or both. All right. So, let's just focus on the offer side. I forgot to put the little thing so that it uh comes one at a time, so I apologize. So, thes... Read More

Key Insights

• Strong offers are differentiated by speed, reduced risk, greater ease, or a combination of these advantages. Businesses in highly comparable markets can escape commodity competition by choosing at least one of these value vectors and designing the customer experience around it.
• Speed is a premium benefit when customers value receiving the desired outcome sooner. A useful planning exercise is to ask what operational changes would deliver the outcome in one-third of the normal time, then determine whether customers will pay enough to support those changes.
• Risk reduction works by protecting customers from the consequence they fear most. Businesses can use warranties, guarantees, or an insurance policy that covers damages up to a stated amount, with the protection cost incorporated into the price of the offer.
• Ease is created by completing preparation and pre-work before the customer must act. Better intake, onboarding, personalized recognition, and attention to small details can make an experience feel seamless because the business absorbs work that customers would otherwise perform.
• Attraction offers can repackage an existing product without changing its core delivery. Giveaways, win-your-money-back arrangements, decoy offers, pay-less-now structures, and buy-X-get-Y-free promotions can make the initial proposition more compelling while preserving the economics through adjusted pricing.
• Giveaway campaigns can generate opportunities beyond the grand-prize winner. A business can contact entrants who did not win and present a second-place benefit, such as a stated discount, turning broad participation into follow-up sales conversations.
• Direct purchase advertising can produce higher return on ad spend upfront, while a lead magnet can produce higher overall return across a longer time horizon. The softer request reaches more people than a purchase-focused message limited to the warmest audience segments.
• Effective lead magnets provide an outcome people actually want in exchange for contact information. The three presented formats are revealing a problem, offering a trial of the solution, and delivering one step from a multi-step process as a smaller splinter offer.
• More videos from this channel:
  • How to price offers for SMBs and keep margins high?
  • How to scale from 600k to 5M in revenue?
  • How to get more leads as a real estate agent
• More from this channel: MoreMozi

Questions & Answers

Q: How do you fix an offer that is not converting?

Fix a weak offer by identifying how it can produce the customer’s desired outcome faster, with less risk, or with less effort. Choose at least one of those dimensions and redesign delivery around it. If the improvement raises operating costs, increase the price to reflect the premium value. The goal is to stop competing as an easily compared commodity.

Q: How can a business make its offer deliver results faster?

Ask what it would actually take to complete the customer’s desired outcome in one-third of the current time. Consider the staffing, contractor pay, scheduling, preparation, and response-time changes required instead of dismissing the idea as unaffordable. Then test whether customers value the faster result enough to pay a price that covers those added delivery costs.

Q: How can guarantees and insurance improve an offer?

Guarantees, warranties, and insurance can improve an offer by addressing the buyer’s biggest fear. A business can guarantee against an unwanted result or obtain an insurance policy covering a defined type of damage up to a stated amount. The cost can be included in the offer’s price, giving customers a concrete reason to perceive the purchase as less risky.

Q: How can a business make the customer experience easier?

A business can make its offer easier by preparing the path before the customer needs to act. That can include collecting useful information during intake, improving onboarding, completing pre-work, learning relevant details about the customer, and coordinating the experience in advance. These actions shift effort from the customer to the business and make delivery feel more seamless.

Q: What promotional mechanisms can make an existing offer more attractive?

An existing offer can be wrapped in a giveaway, a win-your-money-back promotion, a decoy structure, a pay-less-now and pay-more-later arrangement, or a buy-X-get-Y-free deal. Pricing should be adjusted so the promotion supports the underlying economics. Because advertising requirements vary by county and region, the proposed mechanism should also be checked with an attorney for compliance.

Q: Why can lead magnets outperform direct sales offers over time?

A direct sales advertisement reaches people who are already warm enough to consider buying, so it can generate higher return on ad spend upfront. A lead magnet softens the initial request and appeals to a much larger group. When paired with an effective conversion process, that broader reach can produce higher overall return across a longer time horizon and scale further.

Q: What are the three types of lead magnets?

The three lead-magnet formats presented are revealing a problem, providing a trial of the solution, and offering one step from a multi-step process. A problem-revealing asset can identify common mistakes. A trial demonstrates part of the service before payment. A one-step asset separates a useful component from a broader process and offers it as a smaller splinter offer.

Q: Why is a request-a-quote page often a weak lead offer?

A generic request-a-quote page asks visitors to provide contact information without giving them a compelling benefit in return. A stronger approach offers something the prospect already wants and describes the desired outcome in the prospect’s own language. This creates a clearer exchange of value and gives people who are not ready to buy an easier reason to engage.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• Offers escape commodity competition when they deliver an outcome faster, reduce the buyer’s greatest perceived risk, or make the entire experience easier. Businesses should identify at least one of these value vectors, determine the operational changes required, and raise prices when necessary to cover the cost of providing a premium service.

• Risk can be reduced through warranties, guarantees, or insurance covering the customer’s biggest fear. Ease can be improved through thoughtful intake, onboarding, preparation, and pre-work. Existing services can also be packaged with giveaways, win-your-money-back promotions, decoy offers, delayed payments, discounts, or buy-one-get-more-free structures, subject to local advertising laws.

• Direct sales offers can produce higher returns upfront because they reach people who are already prepared to buy. Lead magnets can achieve higher returns over a longer period and scale to a larger audience by softening the initial request. Effective lead magnets reveal a problem, provide a trial solution, or deliver one useful step from a larger process.