CANON VS RED VS FUJIFILM VS SONY - Can You Tell The Difference?

129.1K views
•
March 18, 2019
by
Matti Haapoja
YouTube video player
CANON VS RED VS FUJIFILM VS SONY - Can You Tell The Difference?

TL;DR

Viewers could sometimes tell Canon, RED, Fujifilm, Sony, and iPhone footage apart, but several blind votes were surprisingly close. The test compared eight cameras using 4K where possible, an F2.8 lens, and minimal processing, though different crops and lenses prevented a scientific comparison. Results included a 52% to 48% Canon matchup, so read on for every method detail and head-to-head result.

Transcript

  • A couple months ago, I saw MKBHD do this smart phone blind test, kind of comparing two different smart phones. And he had some really interesting results from that blind test. And I though that would be a really interesting to do with cameras and video, not just iPhones. So I literally grabbed every single I could find around the office, and ones... Read More

Key Insights

  • 🎥 The camera showdown revealed that people cannot easily discern the difference between expensive and cheaper cameras when viewing images online.
  • 🧑‍🏭 It is challenging to compare cameras scientifically due to various factors such as different crops, lenses, and shooting conditions.
  • 🥺 People's preferences for image quality can vary greatly, leading to diverse voting results.
  • 🎥 The camera showdown highlights the exceptional quality and affordability of sub $1000 cameras, making them a viable option for aspiring filmmakers and photographers.
  • 😥 The test also suggests that the cinematography industry has reached a point where even cheaper cameras can produce impressive results, reducing the need for expensive gear.
  • 🎥 The ability to create high-quality content now depends more on the skill and creativity of the person behind the camera rather than the camera itself.
  • 💝 It is important for creators to focus on learning how to best utilize their current camera, rather than constantly chasing the latest and most expensive gear.

Explore YouTube Video Summarizer or Get YouTube Transcript Extractor

Questions & Answers

Q: Can viewers tell the difference between Canon, RED, Fujifilm, Sony, and iPhone cameras?

The voting suggests that viewers could identify some differences, but not consistently or by wide margins. The Canon C300 Mark II beat the Canon EOS R by only 52% to 48%, while 42% preferred the Canon 1DX Mark II over the Red Scarlet-W.

Q: What cameras were included in the blind camera test?

The creator gathered eight different cameras from around the office and from loaned equipment. The group included DSLRs, mirrorless cameras, two cinema cameras, and an iPhone.

Q: Was the camera comparison a scientific test?

No, the creator explicitly says the test was not scientific. The cameras had different crops and used different lenses, making scientifically identical comparisons almost impossible.

Q: How were the camera test settings and post-processing kept consistent?

The creator shot in 4K and used log when each camera supported it, while using an F2.8 lens on every camera. In post-processing, only contrast and saturation were added and matched with scopes, without color grading or color correction.

Q: How did the Sony A7III compare with the Sony A6400?

The images looked very similar, and some viewers wondered whether they came from the same camera. The Sony A7III won with 58% of the vote, although the creator sometimes preferred the Sony A6400 image and disliked the A7III's purple-blue shadow tint.

Q: How did the Canon C300 Mark II compare with the Canon EOS R?

The creator saw substantial differences in color, sharpness, dynamic range, and the overall image, preferring the Canon C300 Mark II. Despite that, the C300 Mark II won by only 52% to 48%, just a couple of votes.

Q: How did the Fujifilm X-T30 compare with the iPhone XS?

The Fujifilm X-T30 won by 69% to 31%. The creator considered this the most obvious matchup because the iPhone XS image appeared out of focus on the face and showed little to no facial detail.

Q: How did the Red Scarlet-W compare with the Canon 1DX Mark II?

The Red Scarlet-W won with 58% of the vote, while 42% selected the Canon 1DX Mark II. The creator observed more saturated reds and less dynamic range in the Canon image, especially in skin tones.

Summary & Key Takeaways

  • Definition: The camera showdown tested whether viewers could visually distinguish expensive camera images from cheaper camera images.

  • Number: Eight different cameras included DSLRs, mirrorless cameras, two cinema cameras, and an iPhone.

  • Tool: The creator used 4K, log when supported, and an F2.8 lens to keep selected attributes similar.

  • Tool: Post-processing added only contrast and saturation matched with scopes, without color grading or color correction.

  • Step 1: Sony A7III beat Sony A6400 with 58% of the vote despite their notably similar images.

  • Step 2: Canon C300 Mark II narrowly beat Canon EOS R by 52% to 48%.

  • Step 3: Fujifilm X-T30 defeated iPhone XS by 69% to 31%.

  • Step 4: Red Scarlet-W beat Canon 1DX Mark II with 58% of the vote, while 42% chose the Canon.

  • Compare: Different crops and lenses meant the showdown was not a scientific camera comparison.

  • Compare: Cinema cameras showed detail without necessarily appearing extremely sharp, while some cameras could appear sharp through added post-processing or in-camera sharpening.


Read in Other Languages (beta)

Share This Summary 📚

Explore More Summaries from Matti Haapoja 📚