Which High-Performance Saloon Is the Best: BMW M5, Audi RS7, or AMG GT 63?

TL;DR

The BMW M5 outshines its competitors by combining impressive hybrid performance with versatility and significant tax benefits, despite its heavier weight. The Audi RS7 offers superior comfort and space, making it ideal for families, while the AMG GT 63 balances sporty aesthetics with solid performance. Ultimately, the M5's fun driving experience secures its top spot in this comparison.

Transcript

was I wrong about the new BMW M5 it has Mega performance but the added way to the hybrid system does count against it to find out if I've changed my opinion on the new M5 I'm going to compare it to the Mercedes mg gt63 which I love and the Audi RS7 performance which I also love and actually ran one as a daily for 6 months to find out which of these... Read More

Key Insights

• The BMW M5, despite its heavy weight, offers impressive performance with a 4.4-liter twin-turbo V8 and electric motor, producing 727 horsepower.
• Audi RS7 features a 4-liter twin-turbo V8 engine, providing 630 horsepower, and is the quickest from 0 to 60 mph among the three cars.
• The AMG GT 63, with its 4-liter twin-turbo V8, offers a balanced performance with 639 horsepower and a 9-speed automatic gearbox.
• In practical tests, the BMW M5 excelled in real-world rolling performance, showcasing the benefits of its hybrid system.
• The Audi RS7 was the most comfortable in terms of interior space and boot capacity, making it a practical choice for families.
• The AMG GT 63, while heavier, provides a sporty interior and a balance between aggressive and elegant design.
• BMW M5's hybrid system offers significant tax benefits for company car owners due to its low emissions.
• Despite initial reservations, the BMW M5 proved to be the most fun to drive, with its hybrid system offering versatility and performance.

Questions & Answers

Q: How does the BMW M5's performance compare to its competitors?

The BMW M5, with its hybrid system, offers the highest horsepower at 727, outperforming the Audi RS7 and AMG GT 63. Although heavier, its hybrid system provides excellent real-world rolling performance, making it a versatile choice for both performance and daily driving.

Q: What are the key advantages of the Audi RS7?

The Audi RS7 is the quickest from 0 to 60 mph and offers the most comfortable and spacious interior, making it ideal for families. It also features a large boot capacity and a practical hatchback tailgate, providing a balance between performance and practicality.

Q: How does the AMG GT 63's design and performance stand out?

The AMG GT 63 combines aggressive and elegant design elements, offering a sporty interior with a 4-liter twin-turbo V8 engine. It provides a balanced performance with 639 horsepower and a 9-speed automatic gearbox, making it a strong competitor in terms of driving dynamics.

Q: What makes the BMW M5's hybrid system beneficial?

The BMW M5's hybrid system not only boosts performance but also offers significant tax benefits due to its low emissions. This makes it an attractive option for company car owners, as it reduces company car tax significantly compared to its competitors.

Q: Why was the BMW M5 initially criticized?

The BMW M5 was initially criticized for its heavy weight, which was thought to affect its handling and performance. However, further testing revealed that its hybrid system compensated for this, providing impressive real-world performance and versatility.

Q: What are the interior features of the Audi RS7?

The Audi RS7 features a simple, classy interior with high-quality materials. It offers comfortable seating for three in the back and ample knee and foot space. However, the sloping roofline may limit headroom for taller passengers, and the infotainment system could be more modern.

Q: How does the AMG GT 63 perform in terms of comfort and practicality?

The AMG GT 63 offers a sporty interior with comfortable seating but is limited to two seats in the rear. It provides adequate knee and headroom for passengers, but the foot space may be restricted if the front seats are positioned low.

Q: What was the final verdict on the BMW M5 after extensive testing?

After extensive testing, the BMW M5 was found to be the most versatile and fun to drive, despite its weight. Its hybrid system offered impressive performance and significant tax benefits, leading to a change in opinion and making it the winner of the comparison.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• The BMW M5, Audi RS7, and AMG GT 63 are compared in terms of performance, design, and practicality. The BMW M5 stands out with its hybrid system, offering impressive power and tax benefits despite its heavy weight.

• Audi RS7 excels in comfort and practicality with its spacious interior and boot, while AMG GT 63 offers a sporty interior and balanced performance. However, the BMW M5's versatility and fun driving experience make it a strong contender.

• The BMW M5's hybrid system provides significant advantages in real-world performance and tax benefits, ultimately winning the comparison despite initial doubts about its weight and handling.