I Wont Be Using XCP-NG And Here Is Why

TL;DR

The video explores difficulties faced while using XCP NG hypervisor for newcomers, particularly around VM management.

Transcript

hey guys what's going on it's Don here from Nova Spirit Tech and welcome back to the channel and today we're going to be checking out xcp now I promise you I tried to like it I really did so let's talk about it now xcp is a fully open- Source hypervisor based on Zen technology now this is to me like a new toy or a shiny new toy that I just received... Read More

Key Insights

• 👶 XCP NG presents a relatively easy installation process but quickly becomes confusing for new users without clear guidance on the next steps.
• ⚾ Many vital functionalities for managing VMs are not easily accessible without using external tools like XCP NG Center, which is Windows-based.
• ✋ The memory usage of XCP NG at first boot is significantly higher than similar hypervisors, raising concerns about efficiency, especially on lower-spec machines.
• 🖤 There’s a notable lack of tutorials tailored to beginners that cover essential tasks without overwhelming details or complexity.
• 👤 The need for a dual environment like Windows for full functionality complicates the user experience for those operating on a Linux system.
• 🙈 The process for expanding storage or VM resources in XCP NG is cumbersome and not intuitive compared to more straightforward implementations seen in other hypervisors.
• 🥺 Despite performance advantages perceived after setup, the initial setup discouragement leads to a negative view of the overall solution.

Questions & Answers

Q: What was the presenter’s initial expectation with XCP NG?

The presenter initially viewed XCP NG as an exciting new hypervisor to explore, particularly due to its open-source nature and the Zen technology it is based on. However, despite these high expectations, he found it challenging to navigate once the installation was complete, leading to a disappointing experience.

Q: What specific challenges did the presenter encounter during his experience with XCP NG?

The presenter faced multiple challenges, including difficulty in creating and managing virtual machines, unclear procedures for using the web interface, and a lack of intuitive guidance. Additionally, he struggled with needing to set up a separate Windows environment just to access essential management tools like XCP NG Center.

Q: How did the presenter feel about the installation process of XCP NG?

The installation process was described as relatively straightforward, with minimal prompts. Once installed, however, the presenter quickly became frustrated as he could not perform vital initial tasks, such as creating or starting a virtual machine, leading to a standstill.

Q: What comparison does the presenter make between XCP NG and Proxmox?

The presenter compares XCP NG unfavorably to Proxmox, citing some features in Proxmox that make it easier to manage VMs. He notes Proxmox's efficient design for expanding disk space, while XCP NG lacks similar functionalities, making VM management feel cumbersome and less user-friendly.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• The presenter, Don from Nova Spirit Tech, shares negative experiences trying to install and use the XCP NG hypervisor, highlighting installation ease but subsequent challenges.

• Key difficulties include a lack of intuitive guidance for newcomers, especially for creating and managing virtual machines without a Windows manager.

• Don compares XCP NG unfavorably to Proxmox, noting issues like limited resources, cumbersome interfaces, and difficulty expanding storage for VMs.