Is It Possible to Get Identity Right?

TL;DR

• Identity is a performance, with sincerity, authenticity, and proficiency playing roles in the paradox of genuine pretending.

Transcript

we got quite a few responses to the previous videos i'm just going to respond to the responses now the first one i want to talk about is from hugh cresswell he said the following where you discussed abigail not performing anymore you missed how it's specifically her not performing the role of ollie anymore not performing the character who she used ... Read More

Key Insights

• 🎭 Abigail's shift from performing masculinity to embracing femininity highlights the paradox of performing identity.
• 🍂 Identity is always performed, with sincerity, authenticity, and proficiency technologies falling short in capturing the complexities.
• ❓ Genuine pretending suggests that authenticity arises from the performance itself, not from an inherent identity.
• ❓ The concept of sincerity, authenticity, and proficiency in identity fails to account for the incongruity of different identity dimensions.
• 👻 Prophilicity allows for dynamic and multiple profiles, contrasting with traditional roles demanding stability.
• 💁 Taoism offers an alternative to authenticity by advocating for genuine pretending in identity formation.
• 💁 The concept of the general peer in identity formation involves second-order observation, uniting with the peer to establish identity preferences.

Questions & Answers

Q: What does Abigail mean by saying she is not performing anymore?

Abigail no longer performs masculinity, embracing her authentic femininity, revealing the paradox of performing gender identity.

Q: How does the concept of genuine pretending relate to identity performance?

Genuine pretending signifies that identity is always performed, with the performance leading to a sense of authenticity for both the performer and the audience.

Q: Why do sincerity, authenticity, and proficiency fail to capture identity accurately?

These identity technologies presume a perfect match between different identity dimensions, leading to identity fundamentalism and pathologies.

Q: How does profilicity differ from traditional identity roles?

Profilicity allows for multiple and dynamic profiles, evolving based on changing expectations, unlike traditional roles that demand stability and coherence.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• Abigail no longer performs masculinity but embraces her true femininity, highlighting the paradox of performing identity.

• The concept of genuine pretending underlines how identity is always performed, leading to authenticity issues.

• Technologies of identity like sincerity, authenticity, and proficiency fall short in capturing the complexities of identity.