4 Unexpected Ways to Win Your Debt Collection Lawsuit

October 23, 2020
by
Consumer Warrior
YouTube video player
4 Unexpected Ways to Win Your Debt Collection Lawsuit

TL;DR

You may win a debt collection lawsuit by participating actively and using four procedural opportunities: seek dismissal when the plaintiff fails to appear, object to telephonic witnesses, compel the debt buyer to produce key agreements, and move to dismiss a stagnant case for failure to prosecute. Filing an answer and attending every hearing are essential because doing nothing can result in a judgment against you. Read on to understand when each strategy may help.

Transcript

  • Hey everybody, John Skiba here. And in this video, I'm going to share with you four unexpected ways that you may actually win your debt collection lawsuit. But first, if this is your first time here to my YouTube channel, go ahead and click subscribe, check on that little bell. That way you'll be notified each and every week, when I put out new v... Read More

Key Insights

  • ☢️ Active participation in the debt collection process is crucial for a favorable outcome.
  • 🥺 Taking advantage of the plaintiff or their attorney's absence in court can lead to case dismissal.
  • 🦻 Objecting to telephonic witnesses may be less effective during the COVID-19 pandemic due to remote court hearings.
  • 📜 Compelling the debt buyer's attorney to turn over important documents can weaken their case and potentially result in a settlement or dismissal.
  • 🥺 Failure to prosecute the case within a certain period may lead to the court dismissing it.
  • 😉 These unexpected strategies can result in winning a debt collection lawsuit without relying solely on substantive legal arguments.
  • 📏 It is essential to stay informed about the specific rules and procedures in your jurisdiction.

Explore YouTube Video Summarizer or Get YouTube Transcript Extractor

Questions & Answers

Q: What are four unexpected ways to win a debt collection lawsuit?

Ask for dismissal if the plaintiff or its attorney fails to appear, object to telephonic witnesses, seek an order compelling important documents, and move to dismiss for failure to prosecute. These strategies depend on active participation and the rules and procedures in your jurisdiction.

Q: Why must you participate in a debt collection lawsuit?

You need to file an answer and appear at the required hearings to preserve opportunities to challenge the case. If you do nothing, the debt collector can obtain a judgment against you.

Q: What should you do if the plaintiff or its attorney misses a hearing?

Ask the court to dismiss the case, even if the judge initially appears inclined to reschedule it. The speaker recommends being respectful but insistent and requesting dismissal with prejudice.

Q: What is the difference between dismissal with and without prejudice?

A dismissal with prejudice prevents the plaintiff from refiling the lawsuit. A dismissal without prejudice permits refiling, although a debt buyer close to the statute-of-limitations deadline may be barred from bringing a new suit.

Q: Why might a debt buyer request a telephonic witness?

Debt buyers may have tens of thousands of cases underway and limited witnesses available to travel. The transcript gives the example of Midland Funding not wanting to fly someone from San Diego to Phoenix for an hour-long trial involving at most $2,500.

Q: Why object to a telephonic witness in a debt collection trial?

An in-person witness is easier to cross-examine and question about documents, and the judge or jury can assess that witness directly. When a court requires an in-person appearance, the debt buyer may offer a low settlement or dismiss the case altogether.

Q: When might an objection to telephonic testimony be ineffective?

The strategy may not work when courts conduct hearings remotely and do not permit courtroom appearances. At the time of the recording, the speaker said court proceedings had been conducted by telephone and that he had not entered a courtroom for about eight months.

Q: How can document requests or failure to prosecute lead to dismissal?

You can ask the court to compel the debt buyer to produce documents such as the sale and purchase agreement, also called the forward flow agreement, which may weaken its case and encourage settlement or dismissal. If the lawsuit remains stagnant for an extended period, a motion to dismiss for failure to prosecute may also be effective, subject to the applicable rules.

Summary & Key Takeaways

  • Participating in the debt collection process is crucial in winning your case.

  • If the plaintiff or their attorneys fail to show up to court hearings, you can ask for a dismissal.

  • Objecting to telephonic witnesses can lead to a settlement or case dismissal.

  • Requesting the court to compel the debt buyer's attorney to turn over important documents can weaken their case.

  • Filing a motion to dismiss for failure to prosecute can be effective if the case has been stagnant for an extended period.


Read in Other Languages (beta)

Share This Summary 📚

Explore More Summaries from Consumer Warrior 📚