Criminal Lawyer Explains the YNW Melly Double Murder Mistrial

TL;DR

A mistrial was declared in the YNW Melly case, leaving the charges pending. The prosecutor can retry the case, negotiate a plea deal, or dismiss the case, but it is unlikely that Melly will accept a plea deal. Melly is expected to remain in jail while awaiting the new trial.

Transcript

now the prosecutor obviously has the discretion to either retry the case or they can negotiate the case or they could just uh dismiss the case they're not going to dismiss a double homicide uh where you're looking at the death penalty they're just not going to and Melly probably isn't going to take any kind of deal because any kind of deal that the... Read More

Key Insights

• 🥺 The jury's question about deadlocked deliberation led to the declaration of a mistrial in the YNW Melly case.
• 💼 The charges against Melly are still pending, giving the prosecutor the option to retry, negotiate, or dismiss the case.
• 😄 Melly is expected to stay in jail while awaiting the new trial, and it is unlikely he will accept a plea deal with life without parole.
• 😑 The defense lawyers expressed both disappointment and appreciation for the efforts of the jury.
• ✋ The defense can request bail, but it is unlikely to be granted due to the high-profile nature and presumption of guilt.
• 👶 Communication with previous jurors is possible, but new jurors will be selected for the next trial.
• 💦 The mistrial provides an opportunity for the defense and prosecution to assess what worked and make improvements for the new trial.

Questions & Answers

Q: What happens after a mistrial is declared?

After a mistrial is declared, the charges are still pending, and the prosecutor can choose to retry the case, negotiate a plea deal, or dismiss the case.

Q: Why is Melly unlikely to accept a plea deal?

Melly is unlikely to accept a plea deal because any deal offered would likely involve life without parole, which he is not willing to accept.

Q: Can the defense request bail for Melly after the mistrial?

The defense can request bail for Melly, but it is unlikely to be granted due to the high profile nature of the case and the obligation of the court to deny bail in such cases.

Q: Can the defense lawyers communicate with the jurors after the mistrial?

The defense lawyers and prosecutors can speak to the jurors after the mistrial, but new jurors will be selected for the new trial, making their insights from the previous trial helpful for preparation.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• The jury in the YNW Melly case had a question about being deadlocked, leading to the judge declaring a mistrial after they couldn't come to a decision.

• With the mistrial, the charges against Melly are still pending, and the prosecutor can retry the case, negotiate a plea deal, or dismiss the case.

• Melly is not likely to accept a plea deal due to the possibility of life without parole, and he will continue to remain in jail until the new trial.