What Did Lt Peter Cistare and Jimmy Schroering Reveal in Sidney Moorer Retrial Day 4 Video Forensics?

TL;DR

Home surveillance explained why investigators did not swab the black Ford F-150: footage showed Sidney Moorer, Tammy Moorer, Ashley, and Ashley's boyfriend cleaning it extensively for several hours, then burning the cleaning rags. The camera system displayed December 23rd, and the truck was searched on December 30th, 2013. Read on for the specific footage, dates, and evidentiary decisions.

Transcript

yes ma'am these are reprints of the digital images that I photographed of the toolbox on that truck and the contents there Thank You Lou today I'm showing you 170 fan that's the only one or more published at this time what do you got a picture up it's a picture of a pack of what swisher Sweets it's like a small cigarette cigar a type of thing and t... Read More

Key Insights

• 👶 The expert analyzed a newer DVR system in the Heather Elvis case and was able to determine two date and time changes on the system.
• ❓ The expert confirmed that there was no deleted footage on the DVR system.
• 🧑‍🤝‍🧑 The timestamp for a specific event was corrected to reflect the accurate date and time.

Questions & Answers

Q: Why did the investigator not swab the black Ford F-150 for DNA?

The home surveillance footage showed the truck being cleaned extensively for several hours. Based on that footage, the investigator did not believe swabs collected on December 30th would provide evidentiary value.

Q: What did the Moorer home surveillance footage show?

The system recorded views inside and outside the residence through cameras positioned around the house. One angle showed the black Ford F-150 being cleaned, while another showed the used cleaning rags being taken to a burn pile and burned.

Q: Who was seen cleaning the black Ford F-150?

The investigator identified Sidney Moorer, Tammy Moorer, Ashley, and Ashley's boyfriend in the footage. They were shown extensively cleaning the truck.

Q: Which parts of the truck were cleaned?

The footage showed extensive cleaning of the outside, particularly the front doors and rear passenger doors. The interior crew compartment was also cleaned extensively.

Q: How long did the truck cleaning continue?

The investigator testified that the cleaning continued for several hours. The extent of that cleaning influenced the decision not to collect swabs later.

Q: What happened to the rags used to clean the truck?

The footage showed the cleaning rags being carried to a burn pile in the yard. The rags were then burned.

Q: What date appeared on the Moorer surveillance system?

The camera system displayed December 23rd for the footage the investigator reviewed. The testimony distinguished that displayed date from the investigator's later examination of the truck.

Q: When was the truck searched, and what was found inside?

The investigator searched the truck on December 30th, 2013, after being unable to enter it earlier. Although the exterior appeared clean, the interior contained debris such as candy wrappers, cups, and crackers.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• Definition: Exhibit 192 was a copy of footage from the Moorer home surveillance system.

• Tool: The surveillance system captured views inside and outside the residence through cameras positioned around the house.

• Who: Sidney Moorer, Tammy Moorer, Ashley, and Ashley's boyfriend were identified cleaning the black Ford F-150.

• When: The camera system displayed December 23rd for the reviewed footage.

• Definition: The truck's doors and interior crew compartment were cleaned extensively for several hours.

• Definition: Cleaning rags were carried to a burn pile in the yard and burned.

• When: The investigator searched the truck on December 30th, 2013, after being unable to enter it earlier.

• Compare: The truck's exterior appeared clean, while its interior contained candy wrappers, cups, crackers, and other debris.

• Definition: The investigator declined to collect DNA swabs because the surveillance footage showed how thoroughly the truck had been cleaned.

• Tool: Still images and surveillance footage were documented because the investigator considered them evidentiary.