The Burrowing Owls in San Francisco and the city's housing crisis may seem unrelated at first glance, but they are both symptoms of larger social and economic changes happening in the city. The height limits, rent control, and permitting process that have contributed to the housing crisis are all products of various movements that have shaped San Francisco's development over the years.

Kazuki Nakayashiki

Hatched by Kazuki Nakayashiki

Sep 14, 2023

4 min read

0

The Burrowing Owls in San Francisco and the city's housing crisis may seem unrelated at first glance, but they are both symptoms of larger social and economic changes happening in the city. The height limits, rent control, and permitting process that have contributed to the housing crisis are all products of various movements that have shaped San Francisco's development over the years.

One of the key factors driving the housing crisis is the changing demographics of the city. As people marry later and employment becomes more temporary, young adults and affluent retirees are moving into the urban core, while immigrants and the less affluent are moving out. The concept of lifetime employment has faded, and San Francisco's younger workers derive job security from a large network of weak ties that lasts from one company to the next. This shift in demographics and employment patterns has put pressure on the housing market and contributed to rising prices and limited availability.

Another factor contributing to the housing crisis is the technology industry's impact on the city. The big wave of the last decade has been social networking, and every notable consumer web or mobile product of this wave has been seeded through critical mass in the "analog" world. Facebook had university campuses, Snapchat had Southern California high schools, Foursquare had Lower Manhattan, and Twitter had San Francisco. These products favor social density, and as tech workers have moved into cities like San Francisco, the industry has changed the city's culture, and the city has changed the technology industry.

The gentrification wave that has swept through San Francisco has been going on for decades longer than the word "dot-com" has existed. San Francisco's progressivism, often mislabeled as socialist or radical, is concerned with consumption, residence, meaning, and community empowerment. The city's first priority is protection - protection of the environment, architectural heritage, neighborhoods, diversity, and overall quality of life. This focus on protection has led to strict regulations and limitations on development, further exacerbating the housing crisis.

One of the unique aspects of housing development in San Francisco is the discretionary nature of building permits. Unlike other major U.S. cities where building permits are as-of-right, in San Francisco, they are discretionary. This means that the approval process for new housing development is subjective and can be influenced by various factors such as neighborhood concerns, environmental impact, and preservationist movements. This discretionary permitting process has contributed to a slower rate of new construction compared to the city's population growth, resulting in a shortage of housing.

The lack of affordable housing in San Francisco is evident when looking at median prices per square foot and the number of new construction permits. San Francisco consistently has the highest median prices per square foot and the lowest number of new construction permits per 1,000 units between 1990 and 2013. The market is producing more housing units for people with above-moderate incomes, leaving a significant portion of the population struggling to find affordable housing.

The consequences of the housing crisis extend beyond affordability. A more elastic housing supply in the Bay Area would not only make living affordable for most people but also allow a larger portion of the population to find jobs and have the financial freedom to save or spend money. The current situation forces many individuals to move to distant areas, spending their money on commuting or even becoming unemployed.

The connection between the housing crisis and the Burrowing Owls may not be immediately apparent, but it highlights the broader issues facing San Francisco. Both are symptoms of larger societal and economic changes happening in the city. By understanding the underlying causes of these issues, we can begin to address them and work towards solutions.

In conclusion, the housing crisis in San Francisco is a complex issue with various contributing factors. The changing demographics, the impact of the technology industry, the discretionary permitting process, and the lack of affordable housing all play a role in creating a shortage of housing and rising prices. To address this crisis, here are three actionable pieces of advice:

  1. Increase housing supply: Implement policies that promote the construction of affordable housing and streamline the permitting process to encourage more housing development.

  2. Preserve neighborhood character: Find a balance between development and preservation by identifying areas where new construction can coexist with the city's architectural heritage and neighborhood character.

  3. Foster community engagement: Involve residents in the decision-making process for new development projects to ensure that their concerns are heard and addressed while still meeting the city's housing needs.

By taking these steps, San Francisco can work towards a more equitable and sustainable housing market that meets the needs of its diverse population.

Sources

← Back to Library

Hatch New Ideas with Glasp AI 🐣

Glasp AI allows you to hatch new ideas based on your curated content. Let's curate and create with Glasp AI :)

Start Hatching 🐣