The Struggle of Notability and the Philosophy of Knowledge

The Struggle of Notability and the Philosophy of Knowledge

Introduction:
In the digital age, the struggle for notability and credibility has become increasingly relevant, particularly in platforms like Wikipedia. The concept of notability is subjective, which raises questions about the border of a "reliable" secondary source. Additionally, the credibility of publications can vary depending on the country. This article explores the challenges faced by creators on Wikipedia and delves into the philosophy of knowledge.

The Struggle for Notability on Wikipedia:
Wikipedia, the massive online encyclopedia, features over 1.7 million biographies, but only 20% of them are about women. The notion of notability is inherently subjective, leading Wikipedia to establish detailed guidelines to determine notability. One of the key factors in determining notability is the presence of reputable, secondary media coverage about the biographical subject. However, this criterion can be problematic when it comes to creators who gain significant recognition within their respective fields. For example, a highly influential creator on a popular app may not be considered notable enough for Wikipedia. This highlights the need for clearer criteria and a more inclusive approach to notability.

The Role of Secondary Sources:
On platforms like Wikipedia, secondary sources play a crucial role in establishing notability. However, mainstream publications often overlook what goes on in creator circles, leaving creators relying on gaming or esports news publications for recognition. Unfortunately, Wikipedia might not consider these publications reputable enough, demanding coverage from established sources like The New York Times. This bias limits the representation of creators and their contributions on the platform. It is essential to recognize the influence of secondary sources while also acknowledging the need for a broader range of reputable publications.

Creators and Their Notability:
Content creators have the power to establish their own notability through their work. With the Creator Revolution in full swing, creators have become influential figures, often trusted more than traditional celebrities. In fact, 92% of consumers trust an influencer's product recommendation more than a celebrity endorsement. This shift in influence challenges the traditional notions of notability and calls for a reevaluation of how creators fit into our documentation and history. The gatekeeping of information by a small group of Wikipedia editors, the majority of whom are male, further emphasizes the need for a more inclusive and diverse approach.

The Philosophy of Knowledge: Shifting gears, the article now delves into the philosophy of knowledge. The concept of the self is examined, highlighting the idea that one's identity is not tied to a central, indivisible entity. The notion that the self is a collection of cells driven by various forces challenges our everyday understanding of identity. This realization leads to the question of what it means to exist and the implications of such a perspective.