Unraveling the Intersection of Data, Philosophy, and Practical Knowledge
Hatched by Glasp
Aug 05, 2023
5 min read
6 views
Unraveling the Intersection of Data, Philosophy, and Practical Knowledge
"๐ Dataview Example Vault, Book Club, & Ecosystem Stats". Glasp now allows users to highlight YouTube video transcripts and export them as Markdown..
"How to Do Philosophy". I learned that I don't exist. I am (and you are) a collection of cells that lurches around driven by various forces, and calls itself I. But there's no central, indivisible thing that your identity goes with. You could conceivably lose half your brain and live. Which means your brain could conceivably be split into two halves and each transplanted into different bodies. Imagine waking up after such an operation. You have to imagine being two people. (note: Interesting thoughts...) The real lesson here is that the concepts we use in everyday life are fuzzy, and break down if pushed too hard.
In the realm of philosophy, we often grapple with abstract ideas that challenge our understanding of reality. The very notion of identity and existence comes under scrutiny, as highlighted in the thought-provoking insights above. It is fascinating to consider the complexities of our existence, questioning the traditional notions of a unified self. These musings remind us that the concepts we rely on in our daily lives are not as concrete as they may seem. They possess a degree of ambiguity that becomes increasingly apparent when subjected to rigorous examination.
People talk so much about abstractions now that we don't realize what a leap it must have been when they first started to. It was presumably many thousands of years between when people first started describing things as hot or cold and when someone asked "what is heat?" that words break if you push them too far. people who want a deep understanding of something are often driven by curiosity rather than any practical need. But that doesn't mean what they end up learning is useless. Knowledge is power. That's what makes theoretical knowledge prestigious. while ideas don't have to have immediate practical applications to be interesting, the kinds of things we find interesting will surprisingly often turn out to have practical applications.
While the pursuit of theoretical knowledge may appear detached from practicality, it is crucial to recognize the inherent value it holds. The desire to delve deep into a subject stems from curiosity, a fundamental human trait. This quest for understanding, although not always driven by an immediate practical need, yields invaluable insights and empowers individuals. The prestige associated with theoretical knowledge arises from its potential to unlock new possibilities and expand the boundaries of human understanding. Intriguingly, even ideas seemingly divorced from practicality frequently unveil unexpected practical applications.
If you write in an unclear way about big ideas, you produce something that seems tantalizingly attractive to inexperienced but intellectually ambitious students. To someone who hasn't learned the difference, traditional philosophy seems extremely attractive: as hard (and therefore impressive) as math, yet broader in scope. There's a market for writing that sounds impressive and can't be disproven. There will always be both supply and demand. So if one group abandons this territory, there will always be others ready to occupy it. instead of trying to discover them because they're useless, let's try to discover them because they're useful.
The allure of obfuscating language when discussing profound concepts can be enticing to aspiring intellectuals. Traditional philosophy, with its reputation for complexity and broad scope, appears captivating to those seeking intellectual stimulation. Unfortunately, this appeal often stems from the misconception that complexity equates to profundity. Consequently, there exists a market for writing that sounds impressive but lacks substance, catering to individuals who are eager to appear knowledgeable without necessarily understanding the subject matter. However, instead of dismissing such territories as futile, we should strive to uncover their utility. By focusing on practical applications and tangible outcomes, we can transform abstract ideas into valuable tools for personal and collective growth.
Once you start using words with precise meanings, you're doing math. It gives people with good intentions a new roadmap into abstraction. And they may thereby produce things that make the writing of the people with bad intentions look bad by comparison. Anyone can do this. Getting to general plus useful by starting with useful and cranking up the generality may be unsuitable for junior professors trying to get tenure, but it's better for everyone else, including professors who already have it. This side of the mountain is a nice gradual slope. You can start by writing things that are useful but very specific, and then gradually make them more general. Philosophy is as young now as math was in 1500. There is a lot more to discover.
By embracing precision in our language and adopting a mathematical approach, we gain a newfound ability to navigate the realm of abstraction. This shift empowers individuals with good intentions to produce meaningful work that exposes the flaws in the work of those with less noble motives. The beauty of this approach lies in its accessibility. It is not limited to a select few but can be embraced by anyone willing to embark on the journey. While the academic landscape may favor specialization and the pursuit of tenure, there is great value in pursuing a path that starts with usefulness and gradually expands into generality. This gradual slope allows individuals to commence their exploration with specific, practical concepts before venturing into broader realms. Philosophy, much like mathematics in the 1500s, is still in its infancy, offering vast uncharted territories for discovery and enlightenment.
In conclusion, the merging of seemingly disparate domains, such as data, philosophy, and practical knowledge, highlights the interconnectedness of human intellectual pursuits. Whether it's the innovative capabilities of Glasp's Dataview Example Vault or the profound insights gained through philosophical introspection, these realms converge to shape our understanding of the world. As we embark on our individual quests for knowledge, it is essential to remember three actionable pieces of advice:
-
Embrace curiosity and seek a deep understanding of the subjects that pique your interest. Even seemingly abstract ideas can have practical applications that may surprise you.
-
Strive for clarity in your communication. Avoid the allure of obfuscation and prioritize precise language, as it empowers others to grasp complex concepts and fosters meaningful discourse.
-
Start with usefulness and gradually expand into generality. Rather than dismissing seemingly impractical territories, explore their potential utility and uncover new pathways that bridge theory and practice.
In this ever-evolving intellectual landscape, let us embrace the opportunities for growth and discovery, for there is always more to unravel and understand.
Sources
Hatch New Ideas with Glasp AI ๐ฃ
Glasp AI allows you to hatch new ideas based on your curated content. Let's curate and create with Glasp AI :)
Start Hatching ๐ฃ