"Mill's Moral and Political Philosophy: A Contemporary Perspective on Utilitarianism and Liberalism"

Hatched by Glasp
Jul 31, 2023
3 min read
2 views
Copy Link
"Mill's Moral and Political Philosophy: A Contemporary Perspective on Utilitarianism and Liberalism"
Introduction:
During his lifetime, John Stuart Mill was highly regarded for his work in theoretical philosophy and political economy. However, his greatest philosophical influence today lies in the field of moral and political philosophy, particularly in his articulation and defense of utilitarianism and liberalism. This article will primarily focus on Mill's two most renowned works, Utilitarianism and On Liberty, while also drawing insights from other texts that shed light on his utilitarian and liberal principles.
Mill's Transformation of Utilitarian and Liberal Principles:
To understand the extent of Mill's transformation of utilitarian and liberal principles, it is crucial to examine his disagreements with previous thinkers like Bentham and James Mill. While Bentham and James Mill viewed happiness solely as pleasure and believed that individuals should predominantly pursue their own happiness, John Stuart Mill expanded the concept of happiness to encompass the development of well-rounded individuals and the role of feeling, culture, and creativity in human happiness.
The Concept of Utility:
Bentham argued that utility not only describes human motivation but also establishes the standard of right and wrong. However, he faced a dilemma in reconciling the ethical claim that individuals should aim for the general happiness with the psychological claim that individuals can only aim for their own happiness. Mill sought to resolve this issue by emphasizing the importance of maximizing value, assigning value to pleasure and disvalue to pain. He introduced variables such as intensity, duration, and extent to calculate the total amount of pleasure or pain associated with different options.
Mill's Doctrine of Higher Pleasures:
While Mill accepted the utilitarian legacy of the Radicals, he introduced significant modifications to their assumptions about happiness. He distinguished between subjective pleasures (a certain kind of mental state or sensation) and objective pleasures (actions, activities, and pursuits that cause pleasurable mental states). Mill's higher pleasures doctrine raises questions about whether these higher pleasures are inherently more pleasurable and whether they align with subjective or objective pleasures. Moreover, his emphasis on the value of intellectual pursuits and the exercise of higher capacities suggests that his doctrine of higher pleasures is fundamentally anti-hedonistic.
Perfectionism and Responsibility:
Mill's perspective on happiness aligns with perfectionism, asserting that human happiness consists in the proper exercise of capacities essential to our nature. He believes that humans are responsible agents, capable of practical deliberation and self-governance. This sense of responsibility involves self-mastery and the ability to regulate actions according to one's deliberations. Mill argues that higher activities that exercise these deliberative capacities contribute significantly to human happiness.
Duty and Utilitarianism:
Mill distinguishes between act utilitarianism, which focuses on right action, and rule utilitarianism, which considers indirect utilitarian theories of duty. He suggests that ethical systems do not require every action to be motivated solely by a feeling of duty, but rather, the general observance of secondary precepts or principles that promote utility. Mill maintains that utilitarianism serves as a criterion of right and wrong, providing a standard for evaluating actions.
Actionable Advice:
- 1. Embrace the development of well-rounded individuals: Like Mill, prioritize the cultivation of various aspects of human happiness, such as feeling, culture, and creativity. Recognize that happiness extends beyond mere pleasure.
- 2. Maximize value through thoughtful decision-making: Consider intensity, duration, and extent when evaluating different options. Calculate the net pleasure or pain associated with each choice to make informed decisions.
- 3. Foster responsible agency and self-governance: Strive for self-mastery and the ability to regulate actions based on practical deliberation. Recognize the importance of exercising higher capacities in leading a fulfilling life.
Conclusion:
John Stuart Mill's contributions to utilitarianism and liberalism have significantly transformed these philosophical traditions. By expanding the concept of happiness, emphasizing the exercise of higher capacities, and promoting responsible agency, Mill offers a nuanced perspective on moral and political philosophy. Implementing his insights can lead to a more holistic approach to happiness and decision-making in our lives.
Resource:
Copy Link