The Power of Variability and Social Dynamics in Mastery and Community Building

Hatched by Glasp
Sep 08, 2023
3 min read
1 views
Copy Link
The Power of Variability and Social Dynamics in Mastery and Community Building
Introduction:
In the pursuit of mastery, variability in practice is often overlooked but is crucial for robust learning and skill development. On the other hand, when it comes to building successful communities, the evaporative cooling effect and the balance between plazas and warrens play a significant role. This article explores the common points between variability in mastery and the dynamics of community building, highlighting the importance of both in their respective domains.
Variability: The Key to Mastery
Variability in practice has been proven to enhance learning and skill development. Research suggests that practicing in varied contexts, using varied methods, and encountering varied task constraints leads to more effective learning compared to mere repetition. Contextual interference, which arises from practicing in varied contexts, improves the transfer of learning to new situations. This allows individuals to identify problems correctly and associate the appropriate technique with each problem. The extra effort required for retrieval strengthens memory, according to psychologist Robert Bjork's theory. Moreover, experts tend to grasp the deep principles of a problem, while novices get distracted by superficial features. Therefore, having multiple methods for arriving at the correct answer is essential for mastering complex skills.
Social Dynamics: The Evaporative Cooling Effect
In community building, the evaporative cooling effect refers to the phenomenon where the most valuable contributors are gradually lost, resulting in a decline in the overall quality of the community. This occurs when the people who are most eager to connect with others are the ones who are least sought after. Openness, allowing anyone to join a community, often leads to the entry of individuals with below-average quality, negatively impacting the community's health in the long run. Social gating, which allows participants to self-select out of a group, can help mitigate this effect. Unequal roles of participation can shift the power gradient and prevent evaporative cooling. However, as communities scale, social mechanisms may break down, causing high-value members to feel a loss of recognition and exacerbating the cooling effect.
Plazas and Warrens: Designing Social Spaces
Two fundamental patterns of social organization, plazas and warrens, offer insights into the design of social spaces. Plazas are characterized by a central, contiguous space where interactions are visible to all participants. In contrast, warrens consist of smaller, interconnected spaces, limiting visibility outside of one's own zone. Facebook exemplifies the plaza design, with profiles, friends, and newsfeeds as warrens, and fan pages, groups, and events as plazas. Twitter, on the other hand, is primarily a warren, except for trending topics, which act as a plaza. Both plazas and warrens have their tradeoffs, with warrens enabling almost perfectly scale-free growth without compromising quality.
Common Threads and Actionable Advice:
Despite their differences, variability in mastery and the dynamics of community building share common threads. Both emphasize the importance of multiple methods, whether in problem-solving or fostering engagement. To apply these principles:
- 1. Embrace variability in practice: Mix up your problems and solutions, seeking opportunities with greater variability. This approach allows for a deeper understanding and the development of multiple strategies.
- 2. Foster diversity in community: Engage with multiple teachers, peers, and styles to expose yourself to different perspectives. This diversity enhances learning and enriches the community experience.
- 3. Balance plazas and warrens: When building communities, consider implementing both plazas and warrens. Plazas provide visibility and hive-like activity, while warrens allow for scale-free growth and individual control. Striking the right balance creates a dynamic and inclusive environment.
Conclusion:
Variability and social dynamics play pivotal roles in both mastery and community building. By recognizing the benefits of variability in practice and understanding the impact of the evaporative cooling effect, individuals can enhance their learning and create thriving communities. Embracing variability, fostering diversity, and balancing communal spaces are actionable steps towards success in both domains.
Resource:
Copy Link