The Current State of Healthcare: Compromises and Profits in the Industry

Ben H.

Hatched by Ben H.

Aug 16, 2023

4 min read


The Current State of Healthcare: Compromises and Profits in the Industry


The healthcare industry is currently experiencing a mix of challenges and successes. On one hand, there are ongoing legal battles over the constitutionality of preventive care mandates under the Affordable Care Act. On the other hand, publicly traded health insurance companies are reporting profitable first quarters. In this article, we will explore the potential compromise in maintaining preventive care mandates and delve into the financial performances of major health insurers. Additionally, we will provide actionable advice for individuals and companies navigating these complex issues.

Compromise in the Courtroom:

Attorneys recently informed a federal appeals court that they are nearing an agreement that could temporarily uphold the government requirements for health insurance plans to cover HIV-preventing drugs, cancer screenings, and other preventive care. This development comes after a ruling by U.S. District Judge Reed O'Connor that deemed some of these mandates unconstitutional. The 5th Circuit subsequently blocked the ruling from taking immediate effect. A three-judge panel of the appeals court is currently deliberating on whether the mandates should remain in place during the ongoing legal battle.

Financial Success of Health Insurers:

During the first quarter of 2023, publicly traded health insurance companies witnessed significant profitability. A standout performer was UnitedHealth Group, the industry leader, which reported a 16% increase in net income to $8.1 billion and a 15% rise in revenue to $91.9 billion. UnitedHealthcare, the company's insurance arm, experienced a 14% growth in net income to $4.3 billion, driven by higher Medicare Advantage and exchange membership, as well as reduced medical expenses. The company's healthcare services subsidiary, Optum, also thrived, with net income rising 19% to $2.7 billion and revenue growing 25% to $54.1 billion. Optum's success can be attributed to increased volumes of OptumHealth patients and OptumRx prescriptions. Notably, Optum is also expanding its physician workforce and recently submitted a bid for Amedisys, a leading home health provider.

The Performance of Health Insurance Startups:

While established insurers enjoyed financial gains, health insurance startups faced a mixed bag of results. Alignment Healthcare narrowed its net loss by 8.4% to $37.3 million and saw a 27.1% increase in revenue to $439.2 million due to growth in Medicare Advantage membership. Clover Health, however, experienced a slight decline in enrollment as the company scaled back its ACO REACH participation. Clover Health's net loss decreased by 3.8% to $72.6 million, but revenue fell by 39.6% to $527.8 million. Bright Health reported a 23% revenue increase to $756.3 million and improved its net loss by 42% to $94.7 million. However, the company is currently exiting the health insurance business due to financial challenges. Oscar Health, on the other hand, reduced its net loss by 48.7% to $39.6 million and recorded a 51% increase in revenue to $1.4 billion. This turnaround was achieved through premium hikes, improved risk-code capture, and renegotiated vendor contracts.

Actionable Advice:

  • 1. Stay Informed: Individuals and companies navigating the healthcare industry should stay abreast of legal developments surrounding preventive care mandates. Understanding the potential compromises and their implications can help stakeholders make informed decisions.
  • 2. Diversify Offerings: Health insurers should consider diversifying their services to enhance financial stability. For example, Optum's success can be attributed to its expansion into healthcare services beyond insurance, such as employing physicians and pursuing acquisitions in the home health sector.
  • 3. Adapt and Innovate: Health insurance startups should focus on adapting their strategies to drive future growth. Clover Health's decline in enrollment highlights the importance of flexibility and agility in responding to market dynamics. Finding innovative ways to improve performance, such as Oscar Health's premium hikes and contract renegotiations, can help startups thrive in a competitive landscape.


The healthcare industry is a complex ecosystem, with ongoing legal battles and financial successes shaping its landscape. The potential compromise in maintaining preventive care mandates underscores the importance of finding a balance between legal requirements and healthcare accessibility. Meanwhile, the profitability of major health insurers demonstrates the resilience and adaptability of established players. By staying informed, diversifying offerings, and embracing innovation, stakeholders can navigate this ever-evolving industry with confidence.

Hatch New Ideas with Glasp AI 🐣

Glasp AI allows you to hatch new ideas based on your curated content. Let's curate and create with Glasp AI :)