The Power of Objective Judgment and Personal Perspective in Communication

The Power of Objective Judgment and Personal Perspective in Communication

In a recent interview, Studio Ghibli's Toshio Suzuki emphasized the importance of not judging people solely based on their titles. At first glance, this may seem contrary to common sense, but the underlying meaning is quite different. Suzuki's intention is to discourage abstract judgments and encourage a more objective evaluation of individuals based on their capabilities.

Often, we tend to have strong preferences, being kind and supportive towards those we like and being excessively critical of those we dislike. However, these preferences are subjective and may not accurately reflect a person's true abilities. By judging people based on their titles and positions, we can objectively assess what they are capable of in their current roles.

Similarly, there is a growing argument that when writing, we should use the first-person perspective more frequently. Instead of using phrases like "there are" or "one might argue," it is suggested to use phrases like "I will give" to present a more intellectually honest and accountable approach. This direct and active writing style effectively conveys concepts and results more clearly to readers.

The crisis of representation is an important consideration in communication. As the saying goes, "There is no view from nowhere." The clearest and most impactful way to make a statement is to start with the phrase "I strongly believe." By beginning with this assertion, the reader or listener is prompted to question why the writer or speaker holds this belief. Consequently, it becomes necessary to provide a rational and persuasive argument for what and how one thinks.

To foster critical thinking, one valuable strategy is to engage students in reasoning and make the logical path of their reasoning explicit through "argument mapping." This tool helps students develop the skills to assess and evaluate different perspectives, enhancing their ability to think critically.

In conclusion, both Toshio Suzuki's emphasis on judging individuals based on their capabilities rather than titles and the argument for using the first-person perspective in writing highlight the importance of objectivity and personal perspective in communication. By adopting a more objective approach to judgment and incorporating personal perspective in writing, we can enhance our understanding, express our ideas more effectively, and foster critical thinking. To apply these insights, here are three actionable advice:

1. Challenge your biases: Reflect on your own preferences and biases when judging others. Strive to evaluate individuals based on their abilities and actions rather than subjective opinions.

2. Embrace the first-person perspective: Experiment with using more first-person language in your writing to present a clearer and more accountable perspective. This approach will enhance your ability to convey ideas and engage readers.

3. Practice argument mapping: Engage in discussions and debates that require you to present and evaluate different perspectives. By mapping out the logical path of your reasoning, you can improve your critical thinking skills and better articulate your thoughts.

By incorporating these practices into our communication, we can create a more objective and effective exchange of ideas.