Why Do Critics Dislike the New BMW M5?

TL;DR

The new BMW M5 is criticized for its weight and appearance, but it offers impressive performance with a 727 horsepower hybrid engine. Despite its heavy build, it manages to deliver a thrilling driving experience with advanced features and aggressive design. However, the added weight affects its handling and power-to-weight ratio, making it less appealing to some enthusiasts.

Transcript

what is everybody hating on the new BMW M5 do people not like the fact that you get this m effect in the ambient liting look at that oh that's very M isn't it so despite that you look at anything online where people discussing it and it's just negativity everywhere what's wrong with people I guess people just don't like change but BMW has had to ma... Read More

Key Insights

• The new BMW M5 features a 4.4-liter twin-turbo V8 engine combined with an electric motor, producing 727 horsepower.
• The hybrid system adds significant weight, making the car weigh 2,435 kg, impacting its power-to-weight ratio.
• The car's design is aggressive, featuring a large M grille, massive air intakes, and a carbon fiber roof option.
• Despite its weight, the M5 delivers impressive performance, with a 0-60 mph time of around 3.41 seconds.
• The interior includes traditional M features like sports seats, M steering wheel, and advanced infotainment system.
• The M5 offers adaptive dampers and a comfortable ride, making it suitable for long-distance cruising.
• The hybrid system allows the M5 to fall into a lower tax bracket, making it a cost-effective company car option.
• Critics argue the car lacks personality and driving engagement due to its weight and extensive driving mode options.

Questions & Answers

Q: How does the hybrid system affect the BMW M5's performance?

The hybrid system in the BMW M5 contributes to its impressive power output of 727 horsepower. However, it also adds significant weight, totaling 2,435 kg, which affects the car's power-to-weight ratio and handling. Despite this, the M5 still delivers strong acceleration and a comfortable ride, thanks to its advanced suspension system and adaptive dampers.

Q: What are the main criticisms of the new BMW M5?

The main criticisms of the new BMW M5 revolve around its weight and design. The hybrid system adds considerable weight, affecting handling and driving dynamics. Additionally, some find the aggressive design less appealing, and the car's extensive driving mode options can be overwhelming. Critics also argue that the weight diminishes the driving engagement and personality typically expected from an M car.

Q: What are the benefits of the BMW M5 as a company car?

As a hybrid, the BMW M5 falls into a lower tax bracket, making it an attractive option for company car users. It offers a balance of performance and efficiency, allowing for a reduced tax burden compared to non-hybrid alternatives. The M5's ability to travel over 40 miles on electric power alone further enhances its appeal for business users seeking a cost-effective yet powerful vehicle.

Q: How does the BMW M5 compare to its predecessors in terms of power-to-weight ratio?

The new BMW M5 marks the first time in the model's history that the power-to-weight ratio has worsened compared to its predecessor. This is primarily due to the added weight from the hybrid system, despite the increase in total power output. The heavier build affects the car's agility and handling, making it less nimble than previous generations.

Q: What are the standout features of the new BMW M5's interior?

The interior of the new BMW M5 features traditional M elements, such as M sports seats, M steering wheel, and M pedals. It also includes a large digital display and infotainment system with M-specific functionality. Soft-touch materials are prevalent, although some have noted a decline in perceived quality compared to previous models. The interior offers a blend of luxury and sportiness, with advanced technology enhancing the driving experience.

Q: How does the BMW M5's design contribute to its performance?

The BMW M5's design includes features aimed at enhancing performance, such as a large M grille for improved airflow, massive air intakes, and an optional carbon fiber roof for weight reduction. These elements contribute to the car's aggressive appearance and help manage the additional weight from the hybrid system. The design also incorporates functional aerodynamics to optimize handling and stability at high speeds.

Q: What are the alternative options to the BMW M5 for performance enthusiasts?

Performance enthusiasts seeking alternatives to the BMW M5 might consider the Audi RS7 or RS6, both of which offer engaging driving dynamics and comparable performance. The Porsche Panamera GTS is another option, known for its superior handling and luxurious interior. For those preferring to stay within the BMW family, the M3 Touring provides a lighter, more agile driving experience with similar performance capabilities.

Q: Why might someone choose the BMW M5 despite its criticisms?

Despite its criticisms, the BMW M5 offers a compelling package for those seeking a high-performance vehicle with advanced technology and luxury features. Its hybrid system provides impressive power and efficiency, while the aggressive design and M-specific elements enhance its sporty appeal. The M5 also offers a comfortable ride and practical benefits, such as tax savings for company car users, making it an attractive choice for those prioritizing performance and practicality.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• The BMW M5 combines a 4.4-liter V8 with an electric motor, generating 727 horsepower. Despite its heavy weight, it offers impressive acceleration and comfort. However, its design and weight have drawn criticism.

• The M5's aggressive design features include a large grille and carbon fiber options. Inside, it provides M-specific features and a high-tech infotainment system. Its hybrid nature offers tax benefits for company car users.

• While the M5 offers strong performance and comfort, its weight affects handling and driving engagement. Alternatives like the Audi RS7 or Porsche Panamera GTS may offer better driving dynamics.