Ilan Pappe: 'minha família sofreu com Holocausto e definição de Holocausto do IHRA é TRAIÇÃO'

TL;DR

Ilan Pappe criticizes IHRA's definition of antisemitism as Israeli propaganda.

Transcript

What's your opinion about uh the definition the anti-semitism definition established by the international holocaust remembrance alliances. First of all, I would would like to say that I really admire President Lola for uh making sure that Brazil does not uh uh is leaving is leaving the the council as as a as an observer. I think that's a huge moral... Read More

Key Insights

• Ilan Pappe criticizes the IHRA's definition of antisemitism, arguing it has been co-opted by Israeli propaganda to deflect criticism of Israel.
• Pappe praises President Lula for Brazil's decision to leave the IHRA as an observer, viewing it as a moral stance that contributes to a better world.
• The IHRA's original goal was to educate about the Holocaust, but Pappe believes it now misuses Holocaust memory to shield Israel from criticism.
• Pappe, whose family suffered in the Holocaust, feels betrayed by the IHRA's current use of Holocaust memory for political purposes.
• Pappe's visit to Brazil faced challenges from a strong pro-Israeli lobby, which attempted to cancel his events and silence his message.
• Despite some events being canceled, Pappe received a warm reception in Brazil and emphasized the importance of educating people about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
• Pappe highlights that attempts to silence critical voices are not unique to Brazil and occur globally when people dislike the message being conveyed.
• His new books, translated into Portuguese, focus on the history of Israeli occupation and the Arab-Israeli conflict, aiming to provide a deeper understanding of the issues.

Questions & Answers

Q: What is Ilan Pappe's opinion on the IHRA's definition of antisemitism?

Ilan Pappe criticizes the IHRA's definition of antisemitism, arguing that it has been co-opted by Israeli propaganda to deflect criticism of Israel. He believes that the IHRA, which began as a good initiative to educate about the Holocaust, now misuses Holocaust memory to shield Israel from legitimate criticism, particularly concerning its policies towards Palestinians.

Q: Why does Ilan Pappe praise Brazil's decision regarding the IHRA?

Ilan Pappe praises Brazil's decision to leave the IHRA as an observer because he views it as a significant moral contribution to a better world. He believes that this decision by President Lula represents a stance against the misuse of Holocaust memory for political purposes and supports a more balanced and fair approach to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Q: How does Pappe feel about the IHRA's use of Holocaust memory?

Pappe, whose family suffered in the Holocaust, feels betrayed by the IHRA's current use of Holocaust memory. He argues that the IHRA abuses the memory of the Holocaust by weaponizing it as part of Israeli propaganda, rather than defending it against denial. This misuse, according to Pappe, detracts from the genuine struggle against Holocaust denial.

Q: What challenges did Pappe face during his visit to Brazil?

During his visit to Brazil, Ilan Pappe faced challenges from a strong pro-Israeli lobby, which attempted to cancel his participation in events and silence his message. Despite these efforts, Pappe received a warm reception and emphasized the importance of educating people about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, highlighting that such attempts to silence critical voices are not unique to Brazil.

Q: How was Ilan Pappe received in Brazil despite the challenges?

Despite the challenges posed by a strong pro-Israeli lobby, Ilan Pappe was warmly received in Brazil. He noted that many people were eager to learn more about the issues he discusses, particularly regarding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Pappe felt that his visit was important for educating the public and was pleased with the overall reception he received.

Q: What are the main themes of Ilan Pappe's new books?

Ilan Pappe's new books, which have been translated into Portuguese, focus on the history of Israeli occupation and the Arab-Israeli conflict. They aim to provide a deeper understanding of these issues, challenging prevailing narratives and offering a critical perspective on the geopolitical dynamics and human rights implications involved in the conflict.

Q: What does Pappe emphasize about attempts to silence critical voices?

Pappe emphasizes that attempts to silence critical voices occur globally when people dislike the message being conveyed. He points out that such efforts are not unique to Brazil and highlights the importance of continuing to speak out and educate the public, despite attempts by some groups to suppress dissenting viewpoints.

Q: Why does Pappe believe his visit to Brazil was important?

Pappe believes his visit to Brazil was important because it provided an opportunity to educate people about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and challenge prevailing narratives. By engaging with the public and sharing his insights, Pappe aimed to foster a deeper understanding of the issues and promote a more informed and balanced discourse on the topic.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• Ilan Pappe criticizes the IHRA's definition of antisemitism, arguing it has been co-opted by Israeli propaganda to deflect criticism of Israel. He praises Brazil's decision to leave the IHRA as a moral stance. Pappe, whose family suffered in the Holocaust, feels the IHRA betrays Holocaust memory.

• Pappe's visit to Brazil faced challenges from a strong pro-Israeli lobby, which attempted to cancel his events and silence his message. Despite this, he received a warm reception and emphasized the importance of educating people about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict through his translated books.

• Pappe highlights that attempts to silence critical voices occur globally when people dislike the message being conveyed. His new books focus on the history of Israeli occupation and the Arab-Israeli conflict, aiming to provide a deeper understanding of the issues and educate the public.