SHOULD I READ THESE 5 POPULAR FANTASY BOOKS?

TL;DR

This content discusses five popular fantasy books and the reasons why the creator has no interest in reading them.

Transcript

hey there my name is megan and welcome back to my channel today i'm going to be talking about five popular fantasy books that were published in the last decade that i really have no interest in reading however i want you guys to give me your opinions and comments and let me know if i should re-evaluate my opinion and maybe pick up some of these boo... Read More

Key Insights

• 😓 "The Priory of the Orange Tree" receives criticism for its standalone nature, extensive cast of characters, and pacing issues.
• ❓ "Black Leopard, Red Wolf" is known for its graphic and violent content, unlikable main character, and triggering themes, which may deter some readers.
• 😀 "Piranesi" faces criticism for being overly descriptive and lacking plot development, potentially resulting in a boring reading experience.
• 🫠 Negative experiences with an author's previous work can deter readers, as seen with the creator's reluctance to read Seanan McGuire's "Every Heart a Doorway."
• 😆 "Gideon the Ninth" attempts to combine sci-fi and fantasy elements but reportedly fails to execute them well, resulting in confusion and an unlikable main character.

Questions & Answers

Q: What are the reasons why the creator lost interest in reading "The Priory of the Orange Tree"?

The creator heard that the book should have been spread out across multiple volumes instead of being a standalone, resulting in underdeveloped characters and a packed plot. The pacing is also criticized, starting slow and rushing towards the end.

Q: Why does the creator not want to read "Black Leopard, Red Wolf"?

The book is described as excessively graphic, with triggering content such as rape and violence against children. The main character is also unlikable, and the graphic descriptions of violent acts make it an unappealing read.

Q: What are the concerns about "Piranesi"?

The creator has preconceived notions about the author, Susanna Clarke, after hearing negative reviews of her previous book. Additionally, "Piranesi" is described as overly descriptive, excessively detailing the house and statues, leading to a potentially boring and tedious reading experience.

Q: What is the primary reason for the creator's lack of interest in "Every Heart a Doorway"?

The creator had a negative experience with another book by Seanan McGuire and disliked it, leading to a reluctance to read any other works by the author. Furthermore, the short length of the book and concerns over plot development also contribute to the lack of interest.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• The first book discussed is "The Priory of the Orange Tree" by Samantha Shannon, which is a standalone fantasy novel with mixed reviews due to its large cast of characters and pacing issues.

• The second book is "Black Leopard, Red Wolf" by Marlon James, which is known for its graphic and violent content, unlikable main character, and triggering themes.

• "Piranesi" by Susanna Clarke is another standalone fantasy novel that is criticized for its overly descriptive writing and lack of plot development.

• "Every Heart a Doorway" by Seanan McGuire is book one in a series about a school for children who have traveled to fantasy worlds, but the short length and negative experience with another book by the author deter the creator from reading it.

• The final book discussed is "Gideon the Ninth" by Tamsyn Muir, which combines sci-fi and fantasy elements but fails to execute them well, leaving readers confused.