Chinese Portable Machine Vs. Italian Espresso Machine

TL;DR

Comparison of Super 58 and Maro X espresso machines.

Transcript

hello guys and welcome to a new video so um the objective of this video is to answer some questions about the super 58 uh espresso machine I have seen a lot of people are still questioning about how it performs uh what is the quality of coffee that it can produce and some people are still asking questions related to it comparing to other machines l... Read More

Key Insights

• The Super 58 espresso machine is not a lever machine, distinguishing it from more precise lever machines like the Flair.
• Super 58 uses a vibratory pump, which lacks the precision of gear pump machines, affecting pressure control.
• Flow control on the Super 58 is limited; pressure jumps to maximum when not fully closed, requiring quick manual adjustments.
• Pre-heating is crucial for Super 58 due to the lack of a built-in heating feature, which can affect espresso quality.
• Both Super 58 and Maro X produced similar espresso shots, though Maro X had a more consistent and stable temperature.
• Testing with a refractometer showed that Super 58 can achieve good extraction percentages, comparable to Maro X.
• The Super 58 is capable of producing quality espresso, challenging the notion that it's a 'plastic toy.'
• Choosing the right grind size is essential for optimal extraction with the Super 58, balancing time and taste.

Questions & Answers

Q: How does the Super 58 compare to lever machines?

The Super 58 is not a lever machine, which means it lacks the precision offered by lever machines like the Flair. Lever machines allow more control over pressure profiling, providing a more tailored espresso shot. However, the Super 58 compensates with some pressure control features, though they are not as precise.

Q: What type of pump does the Super 58 use?

The Super 58 uses a vibratory pump, which is common in many home espresso machines. This type of pump is less precise compared to gear pumps found in professional machines. As a result, users may experience less control over the pressure, affecting the consistency of espresso shots.

Q: Is pre-heating necessary for the Super 58?

Yes, pre-heating is essential for the Super 58 because it lacks a built-in heating feature. Without pre-heating, the machine remains cold, which can lead to a sour espresso due to improper extraction temperatures. Pre-heating ensures that the machine reaches the optimal temperature for espresso extraction.

Q: How do the espresso shots from Super 58 and Maro X compare?

Both the Super 58 and Maro X produced similar espresso shots in terms of appearance and taste. However, the Maro X had a more stable temperature due to its built-in heating system. Despite this, the Super 58 demonstrated its capability to produce quality espresso shots with proper pre-heating and grind adjustments.

Q: What were the refractometer results for the Super 58?

The refractometer results showed that the Super 58 achieved good extraction percentages, comparable to those of the Maro X. The first shot from the Super 58 had a higher extraction percentage than the Maro X, indicating its potential to produce quality espresso. However, grind size adjustments were necessary to optimize extraction.

Q: Is the Super 58 considered a quality espresso machine?

Yes, the Super 58 is considered a quality espresso machine capable of producing good espresso. Despite lacking some features of higher-end machines, such as precise pressure control and built-in heating, it can deliver satisfactory results with proper usage. It's a viable option for those looking for a budget-friendly espresso machine.

Q: How important is grind size for the Super 58?

Grind size is crucial for achieving optimal espresso extraction with the Super 58. The video demonstrated that adjusting the grind size can significantly affect the extraction time and quality. Finding the right balance ensures that the espresso falls within the desired extraction percentage, enhancing the overall flavor and experience.

Q: What conclusion does the video reach about the Super 58?

The video concludes that the Super 58 is a capable espresso machine that can produce quality espresso comparable to more expensive models like the Maro X. It challenges the perception that the Super 58 is merely a 'plastic toy,' demonstrating its potential as a reliable coffee maker for home use. The video aims to assist viewers in deciding whether the Super 58 meets their needs.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• The video compares the Super 58 espresso machine with the Maro X, focusing on their performance and espresso quality. The Super 58 lacks a lever, affecting its precision compared to lever machines. Despite this, it can produce quality espresso shots similar to Maro X.

• The Super 58 uses a vibratory pump, which limits pressure control precision. Pre-heating is necessary due to its lack of a built-in heating feature. The video demonstrates how both machines perform with the same coffee and basket, highlighting their similarities and differences.

• Testing with a refractometer reveals that the Super 58 can achieve good extraction percentages. The video concludes that the Super 58 is a capable espresso machine, suitable for those seeking good quality coffee without investing in a high-end machine.