'Fiancé Wants Prenup but Won't Sign Mine' -- Reddit Story

TL;DR

A couple faces a prenup dilemma as one wants to protect assets, but the other is unwilling to sign one.

Transcript

so it goes fiance 36 female didn't want to sign a prenup with me 33 male got inheritance and now wants a prenup a little background here is that i make around 250k a year my fiance makes around 65k a year we have both been divorced i asked for a prenup protecting my existing assets two rental properties worth around 400k together my retirement acco... Read More

Key Insights

• 📼 Prenups can protect each individual's assets and specify the division of assets in case of a divorce.
• 🫵 Trust issues and differing views on finances can strain a relationship, especially when it comes to prenups.
• 🤵 Inheritances are usually considered separate property in a marriage and may not automatically be shared with a spouse.
• 📭 Having open conversations about prenups can reveal values, expectations, and potential red flags within a relationship.

Questions & Answers

Q: Why is the man hesitant to get married without a prenup?

The man wants to protect his assets, which include rental properties, a retirement account, a house, and savings, after a bitter divorce experience with his ex.

Q: What reasons does the fiancée give for not signing the prenup?

The fiancée believes that everything should be shared after marriage, but she wants to protect her recently inherited estate from the man.

Q: How can prenups affect the division of assets in a divorce?

Prenups can specify how pre-marriage assets are divided in case of a divorce, ensuring a fair distribution based on the couple's agreements.

Q: What compromises can the couple make regarding prenups?

The couple can each have their own lawyers to create fair prenups that protect individual assets while also addressing shared finances during the marriage.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• A man earns significantly more than his fiancée and wants a prenup to protect his assets, but she is against it.

• After the fiancée inherits a sizable estate, she wants a prenup to protect it, but still refuses to sign his prenup.

• The couple faces trust issues and differing views on finances, raising concerns about the future of their relationship.