A man wrote a 16 year old girl getting a boob job and that's just the least of my problems here

TL;DR

In this scathing review, the content creator dissects the problematic writing style, questionable character development, and uncomfortable scenes in the book "Nevernight" by Jay Kristoff.

Transcript

Also, why is he blowing cool breaths onto her? It's not like her vag is on fire. He's like- blowing noises intro music There were a lot of lines that Jay Kristoff wrote that I tabbed here, where I thought, "Hmm... Was that really a choice that you wanted to make and print out in a book?" And after tabbing all of these lines, I realized that I h... Read More

Key Insights

• ✍️ The content creator takes issue with Jay Kristoff's writing style, particularly his attempts at making the protagonist appear edgy and unique, which they find distracting and unrealistic.
• 🧓 They question the decision to categorize the book as adult fantasy while featuring a 16-year-old protagonist who appears more mature and hardened than her age suggests.
• 💬 The content creator comments on the excessive usage of metaphors and similes, finding them forced and detracting from the overall reading experience.

Questions & Answers

Q: Is the content creator familiar with Jay Kristoff's other works?

The content creator admits to being unaware of Jay Kristoff's previous works before reading "Nevernight" but mentions an incident involving the author's controversial comments on Twitter.

Q: What are some specific examples of problematic writing in the book?

The content creator highlights moments where the protagonist's appearance is overly described in a poetic yet unrealistic manner, as well as scenes that border on inappropriate, such as a sex scene and a teacher-student relationship.

Q: Does the content creator find any redeeming qualities in Jay Kristoff's writing?

Despite their criticisms, the content creator acknowledges Jay Kristoff's passion for writing and his evident enjoyment of his own work.

Q: Does the content creator recommend reading "Nevernight"?

It is implied that the content creator does not enjoy "Nevernight" and does not recommend it based on their critique of the writing style, character development, and questionable scenes.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• The content creator expresses dissatisfaction with Jay Kristoff's writing style and accuses him of trying to make the 16-year-old protagonist appear edgy and unrealistic.

• They criticize the mismatch between the protagonist's age and her maturity level, finding it distracting and inauthentic.

• The content creator questions the author's choices, including his usage of metaphors and similes that often come across as trying too hard.