i read this terrible tiktok student-teacher romance so you don't have to

TL;DR

A self-published romance novel filled with poorly written smut scenes, problematic power dynamics, and lazy storytelling.

Transcript

when introduced to an erotic dark Academia romance with a taboo student-teacher relationship most people would see its red flags and not pick up the book I however made the grave mistake of thinking it could be Darkly enjoyable and as punishment for my naivety I ended up reading the worst book I have read all year hello and welcome my name is Leoni... Read More

Key Insights

• 🤳 "Gothicana by Runics" is a self-published gothic romance novel that fails to deliver on its promises.
• ✊ The book suffers from cringy dialogue, poorly written smut scenes, and troubling power dynamics in the student-teacher relationship.
• 🖤 The author clearly lacked research, resulting in grammatical errors and inaccuracies regarding academic topics.
• 🧑‍⚕️ The portrayal of mental health is problematic and fails to address the complexities of the subject matter.
• 🛝 The book emphasizes aesthetic elements such as graphic design and music, but fails to develop a compelling story or well-rounded characters.
• 🎮 The possessive and controlling behavior in the romance is not adequately addressed or critiqued.
• 🖤 The plot twists and mystery elements in the book feel forced and lack suspense or coherence.

Questions & Answers

Q: What are the major flaws of "Gothicana by Runics"?

The book suffers from poor writing, including fan fiction-like dialogue, possessive and problematic power dynamics, ineffective character development, and a lack of depth in exploring dark academia.

Q: Does the author address the problematic elements in the student-teacher romance?

No, the author does not effectively address the power imbalance or consent in the student-teacher relationship. The possessive and controlling behavior of the teacher is presented as romantic, which is problematic.

Q: Are there any redeeming qualities in the book?

The book's graphic design, playlist, and inclusion of a map are commendable. However, these superficial elements cannot redeem the overall poor quality of the story and characters.

Q: How does the book handle mental health portrayals?

The book portrays mental health issues poorly, romanticizing a borderline abusive relationship and failing to provide accurate and sensitive depictions of mental health struggles.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• "Gothicana by Runics" is a self-published romance novel set in a secretive university situated in a Gothic castle.

• The book contains cringy flirting, badly written smut scenes, and troubling depictions of mental health.

• The author's lack of research is evident, as there are grammatical errors and inaccuracies regarding academic topics.