McStay Family Murder Trial Day 37 Part 2

TL;DR

A detective's report and interview transcripts reveal inconsistent statements regarding the futon covers found at the crime scene.

Transcript

yes it's consistent she talked about finding the futon covered the laundry area that's what she believed this is what she believed yes there was multiple covers there I believe she stated she fucked over 40 she kind of went back and forth but pretty stuck with the four let those pillows or cushions a three-second on it was for breakfast that's what... Read More

Key Insights

• 📔 The witness's statements about the futon covers were inconsistent throughout the interview.
• 🕵️ The detective's report focused on the witness's belief that the covers were only for the pillows, not the larger portion of the futon.
• 🕵️ The inclusion of drawings and pictures in the case file is uncertain, and the detective does not recall specific details.

Questions & Answers

Q: Why did the detective's report not mention that the witness was trying to put on the larger futon cover?

The detective wrote the report based on the witness's statements that the larger cover didn't fit. They formed the opinion that the covers were only for the pillows based on the totality of the interview.

Q: Were the drawings of the crime scene included in the case file?

It is unclear if the drawings were included in the case file or entered as evidence. The detective does not specifically remember seeing them.

Q: Did the detective note which pictures were shown during the interview?

The detective only recalls two pictures shown during the interview: one of Joseph Jr. and Gianni on the futon eating popcorn and another of an empty bedroom with the futon covers. It is unclear if the detective noted which ones were shown.

Q: Was the detective aware of reports linking the futon cover to the crime scene?

The detective testified that there were suspicions about the futon cover being wrapped around Joseph, but no specific reports stating this were mentioned.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• The detective's report states that the witness believed she found multiple futon covers and tried to put them on, but they were only for the pillows, not the larger portion of the futon.

• The detective's report did not mention that the witness was trying to put on the larger cover, stating that it didn't fit based on the witness's statements.

• There were drawings of the crime scene, but it is unclear if they were included in the case file or entered as evidence.

• Pictures were shown during the interview, but it is unclear if the detective noted which ones were shown.