Bill Kristol on Kevin McCarthy's Crass Revisionism

TL;DR

Teen Vogue editor-in-chief resigns after backlash over decade-old tweets, highlighting the cancel culture's unforgiving nature.

Transcript

welcome to the bulwark podcast i'm charlie sykes this is our weekend podcast so we bring out the big guns bill crystal joining us today bill how are you how have you managed to navigate the first week of daylight savings time i i'm i'm fine and thank you i'm so flattered to be called a big gun i think i should just you know quit while i'm ahead her... Read More

Key Insights

• 🥹 Cancel culture continues to hold individuals accountable for past actions, no matter how old those actions are or the apologies made.
• 💗 There is a growing divide between the "cancelers" and those who advocate for forgiveness and second chances.

Questions & Answers

Q: What were the tweets that caused the controversy?

The tweets that caused the controversy were from when Alexi McCammond was 17 years old, and they included mocking remarks about Asian Americans and using slurs.

Q: Did McCammond apologize for her tweets?

Yes, McCammond apologized profusely and repeatedly for the tweets, both when they resurfaced in 2019 and more recently when the controversy erupted.

Q: Was the decision to resign her own choice?

It's unclear whether the decision to resign was entirely McCammond's choice or if there was pressure from within the organization due to the controversy.

Q: How did progressive journalists react to McCammond's resignation?

Progressive journalists such as Mehdi Hasan and Chris Hayes expressed frustration over the disproportionate consequences for past actions and emphasized the need for forgiveness and a sense of proportion.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• Alexi McCammond, an African-American journalist, resigns as editor-in-chief of Teen Vogue due to controversy over tweets she made when she was 17 years old.

• Despite apologizing for the tweets multiple times, the backlash was relentless, showing the cancel culture's refusal to forgive and allow for growth.

• Progressive journalists, such as Mehdi Hasan and Chris Hayes, express frustration over the disproportionate consequences for past actions and the lack of forgiveness in society.