Got a novel idea? what to do next. #science #strategy #academia #publishing #phd #phdlife

TL;DR

When faced with a novel idea, researchers must decide whether to write an opinion paper or conduct an experimental study, weighing the speed and advantage of publishing against the potential diminished novelty.

Transcript

hey there friends so this video is about the situation when you have a what you think is a very novel and cool idea and it is upon you to decide what to do with it where to go what to do is the next step and there's two fundamental choices what you can do typically is one you can write an opinion perspective or viewpoint paper to get that idea out ... Read More

Key Insights

• 💨 Publishing an opinion paper quickly can give researchers an advantage in fast-moving fields.
• 😫 Writing an opinion paper may diminish the novelty of the idea when setting up an experiment or study.
• 🏮 The difficulty and risk involved in conducting a study should be considered when deciding between an opinion paper and an experimental study.
• 💡 The potential impact and novelty of the idea should also be evaluated.
• 🏮 Current events or upcoming policy decisions can provide momentum for writing an opinion paper.
• 🏮 Researchers can consider combining ideas from multiple opinion papers to create a more impactful and comprehensive paper.
• 💡 The decision on whether to write an opinion paper or conduct an experiment is critical in maximizing the potential of a novel idea.

Questions & Answers

Q: What are the two fundamental choices researchers have when they have a novel idea?

Researchers can choose to write an opinion paper to quickly share their idea or start designing experiments to test the idea.

Q: What advantage does publishing an opinion paper offer in fast-moving fields?

By publishing an opinion paper, researchers can ensure that their idea is out there before someone else publishes a similar idea, giving them an advantage.

Q: What is the downside of writing an opinion paper before conducting an experiment?

The downside is that the idea may lose its novelty when the experiment or study is set up, as the previously published opinion paper has already detailed the idea.

Q: What factors should researchers consider when deciding between an opinion paper and an experimental study?

Researchers should consider the difficulty, risk, logistics, and time involved in conducting the study. They should also evaluate the novelty and potential impact of their idea.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• Researchers have two fundamental choices when deciding what to do with a novel idea: write an opinion paper or start designing experiments.

• Publishing an opinion paper quickly can be advantageous in fast-moving fields, ensuring the idea is out there before someone else publishes it.

• However, publishing an opinion paper may reduce the novelty of the idea when setting up an experiment or study, as the two papers may start competing with each other.