Dalia Dippolito Retrial Jury Goes Home for the Night 12/13/16

TL;DR

The judge discusses the jury's inability to reach a unanimous decision and plans for further deliberations.

Transcript

are you yeah I was on no yeah come oh my God and get there and push my back and I got to please rise andt we are back in session please be seated we have the following note from the jury we the jury feel that we cannot reach a unanimous decision my plan is as follows my plan is to send them home this evening bring them back at 9:30 if they give me ... Read More

Key Insights

• 🧑‍⚖️ The jury's inability to reach a unanimous decision is causing the judge to consider alternate plans.
• 🥳 The judge wants to give the jury time to rest and return the next day to continue deliberations.
• 👨‍🔬 Strict instructions are given to the jury to ensure they do not discuss the case outside of the jury room or conduct any research.
• 🫠 The judge is prepared to read the Allen charge if the jury continues to struggle with reaching a unanimous decision.

Questions & Answers

Q: Why is the judge considering sending the jury home?

The jury has sent a note stating that they cannot reach a unanimous decision, so the judge is considering giving them more time to deliberate.

Q: What instructions are given to the jury?

The jury is reminded not to communicate with anyone about the case, even each other, outside of the jury room. They are also instructed not to conduct any research or listen to news related to the trial.

Q: What will happen if the jury sends a similar note the next day?

If the jury sends a similar note the next day, the judge will read the Allen charge, which gives further instructions and encourages the jury to reach a unanimous decision.

Q: Why does the judge decide not to make an inquiry about staying overnight?

The judge decides not to make an inquiry about staying overnight because there is no reason to keep the jury late, and the courtroom needs to close in 30 minutes.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• The jury is unable to reach a unanimous decision, leading the judge to plan for further deliberations.

• The judge decides to send the jury home for the evening and bring them back the next day.

• Instructions are given to the jury, reminding them not to communicate about the case outside the jury room or engage in any research.