Bob Bianchi & Judges Ashley Willcott & William Dawson Discuss the Marshae Jones Case 07/03/19

TL;DR

Marcia Jones, a pregnant woman involved in an altercation that resulted in the death of her baby, has been indicted for manslaughter, but it remains questionable whether the prosecution can prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt.

Transcript

I welcome back to the law and crime Network if it weren't enough that I got Judge William Dawson with me obviously excellent judge in many regards up to and including his philosophy of life which i think is so important when we do what we do but we have one of our very own here at the law in crime network another judge judge Ashley will cop my frie... Read More

Key Insights

• 🤨 The indictment against Marcia Jones raises questions about the application of the reckless standard in manslaughter cases.
• 😒 The possibility of foreseeing the use of deadly force in a confrontation is an important factor in determining the culpability of the parties involved.
• 👍 The decision of whether to proceed with the charges against Jones depends on the evidence presented and the ability of the prosecution to prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt.

Questions & Answers

Q: What is the basis for the indictment against Marcia Jones?

Marcia Jones has been indicted for manslaughter, with the argument being that her confrontation with the other woman resulted in the deadly shootout.

Q: Why was the indictment against the woman who shot Jones dismissed?

The indictment against the woman who shot Jones was dismissed by prosecutors, and the reason for this decision is unknown.

Q: Can the prosecution prove the case against Jones beyond a reasonable doubt?

It is questionable whether the prosecution can prove the case against Jones beyond a reasonable doubt, given the uncertainty of whether Jones could have foreseen the use of deadly force in the altercation.

Q: Are there concerns about the application of the reckless standard in this case?

There are concerns about the application of the reckless standard in this case, as it may extend to situations where a reasonable person would not anticipate the use of deadly force.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• Marcia Jones, who was noticeably pregnant, got into an argument with another woman, resulting in the woman shooting her in the stomach and killing her baby.

• Jones has been indicted for manslaughter, with the argument being that she brought the altercation upon herself by confronting the other woman.

• The decision of whether the charges will proceed against Jones is pending, and there are concerns about the application of the reckless standard and the possibility of foreseeing the use of deadly force.