7 Worst Things Black Noir Has Done In The Comics That The TV Series CAN’T Show You! | Summary and Q&A

TL;DR

Black Noir's comic actions reveal him as a truly horrific character.

Key Insights

• 🦸 Black Noir is a clone of Homelander created to replace him if he becomes uncontrollable, depicting a dark twist in superhero lore.
• 🧑‍🏭 In the comics, he is responsible for heinous acts, overshadowing his portrayal as comic relief in the TV series.
• ✋ His actions include framing Homelander for atrocities he committed, showcasing a high level of psychological manipulation.
• 🤬 Black Noir's sadism extends to acts of cannibalism and sexual violence, marking him as a symbol of extreme moral corruption.
• ✊ His backstory intertwines with significant themes of power abuse, offering a critique of toxic corporate cultures in entertainment.
• 📺 The chilling differences between the comic and TV portrayals illustrate how adaptation can reshape character narratives and themes.
• 🧔‍♀️ Black Noir's violent actions against women mirror real societal issues, particularly concerning workplace harassment and the culture of impunity.

Transcript

Read and summarize the transcript of this video on Glasp Reader (beta).

Questions & Answers

Q: How does Black Noir differ from his TV counterpart in terms of character backstory?

In the comics, Black Noir is a genetically engineered clone of Homelander with all his powers but none of his autonomy. His creators intended for him to be a contingency against Homelander's potential rogue behavior. Unlike the more nuanced portrayal in the show, comic Noir lacks empathy, which leads to disturbing acts that showcase his malevolence and plan to replace Homelander.

Q: What are some of the horrific acts that Black Noir commits in the comics?

Some of Black Noir's most egregious acts include framing Homelander for murders he committed, sexually assaulting Starlight, and killing Becca Butcher after assaulting her, leading to a traumatic childbirth. He even engages in cannibalism, consuming children, illustrating his complete moral depravity. These actions paint him as the worst superhero (soup) in existence.

Q: Why is Black Noir's character considered one of the worst in comic lore?

Black Noir epitomizes the archetype of a pure villain in superhero comics. His actions not only include murder, framing others for his crimes, and acts of violence, but he also manipulates and psychologically torments those around him. This lack of redeeming qualities and the sheer brutality of his deeds contrast sharply with more complex characters, enhancing his reputation as a horrifying figure.

Q: How does Black Noir’s portrayal in the comics reflect workplace issues?

Black Noir's actions, especially his sexual assault of Starlight, symbolize a toxic corporate culture where oppressive power dynamics can lead to abuse. The portrayal captures how self-serving leaders can mistreat subordinates with complete impunity, reflecting grim realities that mirror issues of sexual harassment and power misuse in real workplaces, albeit in an exaggerated, fictional context.

Q: What were the circumstances surrounding Becca Butcher's fate in the comics?

In the comics, Black Noir is responsible for the assault on Becca Butcher, resulting in her tragic pregnancy and the death of her child, which she endures alone. Unlike in the TV show, where Becca survives, the comic narrative emphasizes the horrific aftermath of her assault, showcasing the raw brutality of Black Noir's character and the psychological trauma affecting Billy Butcher as a result.

Q: How does Black Noir’s actions catalyze Homelander’s insanity in the comics?

Black Noir’s orchestrated plan involves committing horrific crimes while framing Homelander, pushing him into a psychological breakdown. His manipulations lead Homelander to dissociate from reality, believing he is responsible for actions he didn’t commit, creating an unstable relationship with his identity and ultimately allowing Black Noir to fulfill his dark purpose.

Q: What can fans of the TV show learn about Black Noir from the comics?

Fans of the show may find the comic version of Black Noir jarring, as it reveals a deeply sadistic and malevolent character. Unlike in the series, where he exhibits a veneer of honor, the comics portray him devoid of compassion or heroism, culminating in a stark reminder of how character interpretations can vary significantly across media.

Q: How do the comics portray the theme of power and abuse within the superhero dynamic?

The comics present a disturbing exploration of power dynamics within superhero hierarchies, primarily through Black Noir's heinous actions. They illustrate how toxicity can permeate organizations, leading to abuse, manipulation, and a lack of accountability, which serves to critique not just the world of superheroes, but societal realities regarding authority and oppression.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• Black Noir, in the comics, is a clone of Homelander, created to replace him if he goes rogue while being forced to be his friend, driving him insane.

• His vile actions include framing Homelander for egregious crimes, such as assaulting Starlight and killing Billy Butcher’s wife, Becca, after an assault that involved a tragic childbirth.

• Unlike the TV portrayal, comic Black Noir is devoid of humanity and committed heinous acts, including murder and cannibalism, solidifying his position as one of the darkest characters in the series.