The Impact of Gamification and Behaviorist Theory on User Engagement

Hatched by Glasp
Aug 26, 2023
3 min read
2 views
Copy Link
The Impact of Gamification and Behaviorist Theory on User Engagement
Introduction:
In today's digital age, where the online world is intertwined with our daily lives, companies are constantly seeking innovative ways to engage users and keep them coming back for more. Two concepts that have been explored extensively in this realm are gamification and behaviorist theory. However, recent developments have shown that these approaches may not always deliver the desired results. This article will delve into the reasons behind the decline of Foursquare and the limitations of B.F. Skinner's teaching machine, highlighting common points and offering actionable advice for businesses seeking to enhance user engagement.
The Decline of Foursquare:
Foursquare, once hailed as a pioneer in the social local mobile revolution, has been struggling to retain its user base. One of the key reasons behind this decline is its overreliance on gamification. While gamification initially garnered attention and engagement, it has proven to be less relevant to smartphone users over time. Foursquare recognized this and shifted its focus to prioritize local search and discovery, following the footsteps of platforms like Yelp. This shift highlights the importance of adapting to user preferences and needs.
The Limitations of Behaviorist Theory:
B.F. Skinner's teaching machine, based on behaviorist theory, aimed to manipulate behaviors through rewards and punishments. However, this approach violated two key principles of the theory. Firstly, students were not provided with immediate feedback on their performance, hindering their learning process. Secondly, behaviorists insisted on analyzing behaviors rather than speculating about inward motivations or sensations. This limited approach failed to encompass the complexity of human learning and engagement.
Connecting the Dots:
While seemingly unrelated, the decline of Foursquare and the limitations of Skinner's teaching machine share common threads. Both approaches emphasize the importance of external motivators, be it gamification or rewards and punishments. However, they overlook intrinsic motivation and the innate desire for autonomy, mastery, and purpose. Users and students alike seek meaningful experiences that go beyond superficial incentives.
Actionable Advice:
- 1. Embrace Intrinsic Motivation: Businesses should focus on creating products and experiences that tap into users' intrinsic motivation. By providing value, meaningful content, and personalized experiences, companies can foster long-term engagement.
- 2. Incorporate Immediate Feedback: Feedback is crucial for learning and growth. Whether in the classroom or the digital realm, providing users with immediate feedback on their actions enhances their understanding and encourages them to continue engaging.
- 3. Balance Extrinsic and Intrinsic Motivators: While external motivators like rewards and gamification can be effective in the short term, businesses must strike a balance between extrinsic and intrinsic motivators. By creating a holistic experience that includes both, companies can create a sustainable engagement model.
Conclusion:
The decline of Foursquare and the limitations of Skinner's teaching machine shed light on the importance of understanding user motivation and engagement. As businesses strive to capture and retain users' attention, it is crucial to consider the limitations of external motivators and embrace intrinsic motivation. By incorporating immediate feedback and striking a balance between extrinsic and intrinsic motivators, companies can create engaging experiences that stand the test of time.
Resource:
Copy Link