Joe Rogan Experience #606 - Randall Carlson | Summary and Q&A

TL;DR

Randall Carlson discusses cataclysmic events shaping ancient civilizations and recent climate changes.

Key Insights

• 😥 Geological evidence points to catastrophic events shaping ancient civilizations and abrupt climate changes.
• 🤢 Sea level rise spikes and extinction events coincide with rapid warming and cooling periods in Earth's history.
• 🫵 Criticisms of uniformitarian views in geology highlight the need to consider catastrophic processes alongside gradualism.
• 🎨 Modern examples of glacial floods pale in comparison to the grand scale events proposed by Carlson in ancient history.
• ☠️ Historical evidence of mammoth cemeteries and massive bone deposits contradicts theories of human-driven mass extinctions.
• 👨‍🔬 Randall Carlson's research challenges mainstream geological narratives, emphasizing the role of cataclysmic events in shaping Earth's history.
• 🫥 Evidence of tree lines and fossil plant remains indicate dramatic climate changes in ancient times, supporting Carlson's theories.

Transcript

makes it look like we're on a radio show yeah check it out the joe rogan experience train by day joe rogan podcast by night all day yes ladies and gentlemen welcome back randall carlson how are you sarah i'm doing well joe you freaked out the entire uh podcast population the last time you were here with your stories of cataclysmic disasters and and... Read More

Questions & Answers

Q: What evidence supports the abrupt climate changes and extinction events in ancient history?

Geological records, such as sea level rises and mega mammal extinction spikes, coincide with drastic warming and cooling events.

Q: How do modern examples of glacial floods compare to the grand scale catastrophic flooding proposed by Randall Carlson?

Modern examples are minuscule compared to the geological evidence of massive glacial floods causing rapid climate changes and extinction during ancient times.

Q: What challenges did early geologists face in proposing catastrophic events in Earth's history?

Early geologists faced backlash for deviating from the uniformitarian view, with critics rejecting notions of catastrophes shaping Earth's past.

Q: How does Randall Carlson's work challenge conventional beliefs about gradualism in geological processes?

Carlson's research highlights rapid, catastrophic events shaping Earth's history, challenging the dogma of gradualism in geological explanations.

Summary

In this podcast episode, Joe Rogan interviews Randall Carlson, a geologist, about cataclysmic events and the evidence of asteroidal impacts. They discuss a long excursion Carlson took with Graham Hancock to show him landscapes related to Hancock's theories about a lost civilization. Carlson explains how research since 1995 has opened the window onto the extreme events that occurred 11 to 13,000 years ago, which separated modern history from deep history. He presents graphs showing temperature changes over time and explains the significant cooling periods and warming spikes that have occurred. Carlson also discusses the correlation between the climate changes and the rise and fall of civilizations throughout history.

Questions & Answers

Q: What is the nature of the excursion that Carlson took with Graham Hancock?

Carlson took Hancock on a tour to show him landscapes related to Hancock's theories about a lost civilization in prehistoric times. The excursion was for Hancock's sequel to "Fingerprints of the Gods." They visited places that were affected by cataclysmic events, which were not specific in Hancock's first book.

Q: What were some of the criticisms of Hancock's theories about a lost civilization?

Critics attacked Hancock's theories by questioning the lack of evidence for a lost civilization. They asked for physical evidence such as pottery, carvings, and infrastructure. Carlson explains that additional research since 1995 has provided more evidence for the catastrophic events that occurred 11 to 13,000 years ago, which explains the lack of hard evidence before that.

Q: What is the difference between modern history and deep history?

Modern history, which goes back about 5 to 6,000 years, is separated from deep history by the extreme events that occurred 11 to 13,000 years ago. Carlson describes deep history as a time period that is almost unrecognizable from our modern world. The changes during this time include sea levels going down hundreds of feet and massive ice sheets covering North America and Europe.

Q: What is the significance of structures like Göbekli Tepe and Gunung Padang?

These structures, which are at least 11 to 12,000 years old, provide more evidence for civilizations that existed before recorded history. Carlson believes that Göbekli Tepe is far less than 10% excavated and the preliminary findings suggest that it was deliberately buried. He speculates that it may have been buried to protect it from aerial bursts or energetic events, similar to how modern structures are buried to protect them.

Q: How did our ancestors in deep history interact with the sky?

According to Carlson, our ancestors in deep history had an obsessive concern with events in the sky. Ancient structures like Stonehenge and Göbekli Tepe exhibit astronomical alignments that suggest a sophisticated understanding of observations in the sky. Carlson argues that this fascination with the sky may have been a result of the extreme events that occurred during deep history.

Q: What was civilization like before the rebooting of civilization in deep history?

Carlson explains that before the rebooting of civilization, modern humans had been on the planet for hundreds of thousands of years. However, there is little evidence of what they were doing during those thousands of generations. The evidence suggests that civilization as we know it, with features such as agriculture, cities, and language, emerged about 7 to 9,000 years ago.

Q: How do the Greenland ice cores provide evidence of climate change?

The Greenland ice cores, drilled from the summit of Greenland, provide a record of temperature changes over the past 10,000 years. Carlson presents graphs showing temperature oscillations of 2 to 4 degrees Celsius every 10 to 20 years. He also shows a significant cooling period around 8,200 years ago and a warming spike around 11,000 to 12,000 years ago, which resulted in a nearly instantaneous change in climate.

Q: What does the temperature data from the Greenland ice cores reveal about climate change?

The temperature data from the ice cores shows that climate change has occurred throughout history. Carlson argues that the current debate about climate change should not only focus on human-induced factors but also consider the natural variability of the climate. He believes that carbon dioxide is not the dominant driver of climate change as the data shows significant changes before the industrial revolution.

Q: How does Carlson relate climate change to the rise and fall of civilizations?

Carlson points out that periods of global warming have been times of advancement in civilization, while periods of global cooling have brought about collapses and famines. He discusses how periods of warmth allowed for agricultural expansion and economic growth, leading to advancements in society. On the other hand, cooling led to collapses of agriculture, famines, and diseases that wiped out a significant portion of the population.

Q: Why is Carlson frustrated with the debate on climate change?

Carlson believes that the debate on climate change has become political and focused on carbon dioxide as the dominant driver of climate change. He argues that there is a lack of attention to other factors and evidence, such as the temperature data from the Greenland ice cores. He emphasizes the importance of studying the natural variability of climate and understanding the dynamic nature of our planet.

Takeaways

The interview with Randall Carlson highlights the significant changes in climate throughout history and their impact on civilizations. The evidence from ice cores and historical records shows that climate change has occurred naturally and has both positive and negative effects on society. The focus on carbon dioxide as the main driver of climate change overlooks other factors and limits the understanding of the complex nature of our planet. Studying the natural variability of climate is crucial for a comprehensive understanding of climate change and its impacts.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• Randall Carlson shares geological evidence supporting cataclysmic events in ancient history.

• He delves into sea level rise spikes, abrupt climate changes, extinction events, and rapid civilization collapses.

• Critics challenge uniformitarian views as Carlson presents compelling evidence of Earth's dynamic history.