Your Comments: Law, Foucault, & Crime | Summary and Q&A

14.3K views
June 9, 2017
by
Philosophy Tube
YouTube video player
Your Comments: Law, Foucault, & Crime

TL;DR

Analysis of viewer comments from Law & Order Month discussing Foucault's influence, prison labor, surveillance, religion as panopticon, and reasonable laws.

Install to Summarize YouTube Videos and Get Transcripts

Key Insights

  • 🖤 Foucault's ideas were influenced by black activists, particularly Stokely's writings on politics and war.
  • 🔬 Prison labor is still used in the US, causing ongoing prisoner strikes.
  • 🎥 Some security cameras are fakes, resembling the panopticon concept.
  • ❓ Religion and the panopticon concept differ in the certainty of surveillance.
  • 🤙 The central chamber in the Time Lords' capital is called the panopticon.
  • 🥺 Laws should consider what a reasonable person would find acceptable, but different values can lead to different perspectives.
  • 👮 Democracy doesn't always mean laws are changed by popular vote, as the process can be complex and involve representatives.

Transcript

hello everybody its oli here we've just reached the end of Law & Order month for videos about more justice criminality government surveillance police and prisons and it's time to have a look at some of the comments you've been leaving so the first thing I want to say is that we had two episodes on Foucault and kriti as one-three-five pointed out qu... Read More

Questions & Answers

Q: How was Foucault influenced by black activists' writings?

Foucault's ideas on politics being the continuation of war were influenced by Stokely's book "Stokely Speaks," which discusses similar concepts, showcasing the influence of black activists on Foucault's work.

Q: Is prison labor still commonly used in the United States?

Yes, prison labor is still prevalent in the US, with prisoners essentially being enslaved in some cases. This topic has gained attention due to ongoing large-scale prisoner strikes.

Q: Are all security cameras real or are some just empty shells?

Some security cameras are indeed empty shells, resembling the panopticon, where prisoners are unsure if they are being watched. Personal experiences and reports confirm the existence of fake security cameras.

Q: How does religion relate to the panopticon concept?

While religion can be seen as a form of surveillance, with God watching everything, it differs from the panopticon in that God is believed to be omnipresent and omniscient, seeing everything all the time.

Summary & Key Takeaways

  • Foucault's ideas were influenced by black activists' writings, particularly the similarities between Foucault and Stokely's thoughts on the continuation of war in politics.

  • In the US, prison labor is still used, with prisoners essentially being enslaved, which has led to current large-scale prisoner strikes.

  • Some security cameras are actually empty shells, just like the panopticon, where prisoners never know if they are being watched, influencing behavior.

  • Religion, while similar to the panopticon, differs in the sense that God is believed to see everything all the time, unlike the uncertain nature of the panopticon.

Share This Summary 📚

Summarize YouTube Videos and Get Video Transcripts with 1-Click

Download browser extensions on:

Explore More Summaries from Philosophy Tube 📚

Summarize YouTube Videos and Get Video Transcripts with 1-Click

Download browser extensions on: