Should Politicians be Honest or "Electable?" | Philosophy Tube | Summary and Q&A

August 19, 2016
Philosophy Tube
YouTube video player
Should Politicians be Honest or "Electable?" | Philosophy Tube


The dilemma of electability raises questions about whether politicians should prioritize being honest or saying what voters want to hear.

Install to Summarize YouTube Videos and Get Transcripts

Key Insights

  • 👥 Electability involves a complex mix of practical and moral assumptions, as politicians must balance popularity and addressing concerns with the potential consequences for marginalized groups.
  • 😘 The tension between left-wing and right-wing ideologies within the Labour Party reflects broader debates about political strategy and principles.
  • 💁 The concept of electability can be subjective, influenced by personal politics, information reliability, and the ability to empathize with diverse groups.
  • 😉 A focus on electability raises ethical questions about sacrificing the well-being of certain individuals or communities for the sake of winning an election.
  • 🪜 The unpredictability of election outcomes adds additional challenges to the pursuit of electability and necessitates careful consideration of strategy.
  • 😘 Historically successful approaches to electability, such as Tony Blair's right-wing economic policies, may not guarantee future success or accurately reflect the electorate's desires.
  • 🏋️ Prioritizing electability does not automatically mean abandoning those in need, but it requires weighing the potential benefits and harms of different strategies.


in the West we like to think that all our politicians are dishonest and they're just in it for themselves but here's an interesting question do you really want your politicians to be honest with you or do you want them to be electable this is something that British politics struggles with a lot and in particular the Labour Party I know something ab... Read More

Questions & Answers

Q: Why is there tension within the Labour Party regarding the resurgence of left-wing ideologies?

The tension arises from the party's history of adopting right-wing economic policies under Tony Blair, which contradicts the current left-wing approach advocated by Jeremy Corbyn.

Q: How does the concept of electability relate to addressing voters' concerns?

Electability suggests that politicians must address real concerns of voters, including topics like immigration and crime, in order to appeal to a broad electorate.

Q: What are the potential consequences of prioritizing electability over honesty?

Prioritizing electability can lead to politicians catering to voters' expectations or fears, even if this means perpetuating myths or promoting policies that harm marginalized groups.

Q: How does the unpredictability of election outcomes complicate the idea of electability?

It is difficult to accurately predict election results and understand why past elections have been won or lost, making it challenging to determine the best strategy for electability.

Summary & Key Takeaways

  • The Labour Party in British politics has experienced a resurgence of left-wing ideologies under the leadership of Jeremy Corbyn, creating a tension between differing views within the party.

  • The concept of electability involves practical assumptions about who will win an election and includes considerations of popularity and addressing voters' concerns.

  • The article explores how electability also encompasses moral assumptions, as politicians' choices can give legitimacy to certain ideas and cause harm to marginalized groups.

Share This Summary 📚

Summarize YouTube Videos and Get Video Transcripts with 1-Click

Download browser extensions on:

Explore More Summaries from Philosophy Tube 📚

Summarize YouTube Videos and Get Video Transcripts with 1-Click

Download browser extensions on: