Pentatonix - Shallow - Musician's Reaction | Summary and Q&A

TL;DR

Jacob Restituto analyzes Pentatonix's version of "Shallow" with insightful comments on vocals, production, and instrumentation.

Key Insights

• 👏 Pentatonix's vocals receive praise for a sustained effect enhancing their performance.
• 😥 The cello addition in Pentatonix's "Shallow" cover is a point of contention, with opinions favoring or disapproving of its presence.
• 🎼 Restituto questions the audience's preference for Pentatonix's original music versus their covers.
• 😮 The bass vocal performance by Pentatonix impresses Restituto, leading to a discussion on vocal recording techniques.
• 📔 Potential clipping and audio quality issues are noticed by Restituto, contributing to a deeper analysis of the cover.
• 💬 The audience is prompted to engage with Restituto's content through comments or requests for specific song breakdowns, showcasing a strong connection with his viewers.
• ❓ Restituto appreciates the artistry in vocal layering and arrangement choices, drawing attention to the complexities of Pentatonix's performances.

Transcript

hey what's going on everybody welcome back to my channel my name is jacob restituto i'm a musician from north fork new york and welcome back to another reaction video and these videos like to break down and analyze and talk about all different aspects of your favorite song whether it be the lyrics the production the mixing all different aspects so ... Read More

Questions & Answers

Q: What aspects of Pentatonix's vocals does Jacob Restituto admire in the cover of "Shallow"?

Restituto praises the sustained effect in Pentatonix's vocals, noting a unique quality different from their other songs.

Q: How does Jacob Restituto feel about the cello in Pentatonix's rendition of "Shallow"?

Restituto believes the cello detracts from Pentatonix's vocal performance, expressing a preference for their pure singing without additional instruments.

Q: Does Jacob Restituto question Pentatonix's arrangements in his analysis of "Shallow"?

Restituto queries whether Pentatonix write their own arrangements or have someone else do it, highlighting curiosity about their creative process.

Q: What technique does Jacob Restituto mention in relation to recording bass, comparing it to Pentatonix's bass vocal performance?

Restituto discusses recording multiple bass takes and selecting the best parts, akin to the impressive bass vocal performance demonstrated by Pentatonix.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• Jacob Restituto, a musician, delves into Pentatonix's cover of "Shallow" to discuss vocals, production, and mixing.

• He admires the vocals of Pentatonix but suggests the cello may overpower their performance.

• Restituto questions the audience on whether they prefer Pentatonix's original music or covers.