Jonathan Broyhill Trial Day 10 Part 3 03/17/15 | Summary and Q&A

TL;DR

This analysis provides a detailed review of a charge conference held to discuss jury instructions and the form of the verdict sheet for an ongoing trial.

Key Insights

• 💁 The charge conference served as a crucial step in finalizing the jury instructions and the form of the verdict sheet for the ongoing trial.
• 😌 The discussions revolved around the inclusion of various theories of first-degree murder, including felony murder and lying in wait.
• ⚾ The defense argued for the inclusion of voluntary manslaughter as a lesser included offense based on the claim of extreme emotional disturbance.
• 👮 The prosecution cited case law to support their position on the inclusion of the theories of first-degree murder and the exclusion of voluntary manslaughter.

Transcript

verses of discussing the jury instructions to be given to the jury after the closing arguments as well as the form of the verdict sheet clerk I had three printed copies of some draft your instructions would you provide those to miss Elliot mr. Arbor and mr. faucitt thank you just wait all right let me start again we'll commence a charge conference ... Read More

Questions & Answers

Q: What was the main purpose of the charge conference?

The charge conference was held to discuss and finalize the jury instructions and the form of the verdict sheet for an ongoing trial.

Q: What were the key points of discussion during the charge conference?

The main points of discussion were the pattern jury instructions, including additions or corrections, suggestions for lesser included offenses, and the inclusion of specific elements such as felony murder and lying in wait.

Q: What were some of the issues raised regarding the theories of first-degree murder?

The discussions focused on whether the evidence supported theories of first-degree murder, including felony murder and lying in wait. The defense argued against the inclusion of these theories, while the prosecution cited case law to support their inclusion.

Q: Was voluntary manslaughter included as a lesser included offense?

The defense requested the inclusion of voluntary manslaughter as a lesser included offense, arguing that the evidence supported a claim of extreme emotional disturbance. The prosecution disagreed, stating that the evidence did not support such a claim.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• The charge conference focused on jury instructions and the form of the verdict sheet for an ongoing trial.

• The main points of discussion included the pattern jury instructions to be given, additions or corrections to those instructions, and suggestions for lesser included offenses.

• Some of the key issues discussed were the theories of first-degree murder, including felony murder and lying in wait, and the inclusion of voluntary manslaughter as a lesser included offense.