Is Wokeism Civil Religion? | A Debate with Then & Now | Summary and Q&A

TL;DR

A response to a critique defending vocalism as a force for social justice rooted in Enlightenment values.

Key Insights

• 🙈 Vocalism seen as a mass movement rooted in Enlightenment values for social justice.
• 🤟 Religious elements and capitalist appropriation identified within vocalism gestures like taking a knee.
• 🇨🇫 Critique challenges the concept of the public sphere, proposing a 'general peer' framework.

Transcript

then and now a youtube channel published a detailed response to our critical analysis of wokism and actually presented some sort of defense of vocaism among other things their video included what i thought was a very good description of the notion of civil religion much more detailed than we did in our video in particular of robert bella's concept ... Read More

Questions & Answers

Q: What is the primary defense presented for vocalism in response to the critique?

The video by then and now argues that vocalism is a mass movement for social justice, rooted in Enlightenment values and working towards concrete societal change.

Q: How does the critique address the misrepresentations of the speaker's views?

The critique acknowledges some misinterpretations but emphasizes clarifying statements regarding American religion and civil religion to provide a more accurate reflection.

Q: What is the significance of the taking a knee gesture in the discussion of vocalism?

The critique explores the religious undertones and capitalist appropriation associated with the taking a knee gesture, linking it to broader themes within vocalism discourse.

Q: How does the critique challenge the notion of the public sphere in relation to vocalism?

By proposing the concept of the 'general peer' over the 'public sphere,' the critique questions the individualistic assumptions underlying public discourse within vocalism debates.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• Detailed response to a critique of wokism defense, particularly focusing on civil religion and vocalism.

• Main points include a defense of vocalism as a social justice movement rooted in Enlightenment values.

• Critique highlights the religious elements and capitalist appropriation within vocalism.