Donald Smith Penalty Phase, Prosecution Opening Statements | Summary and Q&A

TL;DR

Homicide is not always considered murder, as it can be accidental or justifiable under certain circumstances.

Key Insights

• 💁 Homicide is a broad term that encompasses both murder and other forms of killing, including accidental and justifiable incidents.
• 👍 In a murder trial, the prosecution must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
• 👍 The prosecution is focusing on proving aggravation, which will help determine if the death penalty is justified in this case.
• 💨 The defense may present evidence of the defendant's brain damage and impulse control problems as a way to mitigate his actions.
• 👍 Prior violent felony is one of the aggravating factors that the prosecution will try to prove.
• 🇭🇲 The prosecution will call a witness who survived an attempted kidnapping by Donald Smith to demonstrate his prior violent felony.

Transcript

each of you a couple weeks ago I had a chance to talk to the sixth grade class prayer dick about my job and a sixth grader asked a really bright question is all homicide murder you might think back to jury selection we talked about that similar topic and the answer is no the killing of a human being of another human being ten in some cases the acci... Read More

Questions & Answers

Q: Is all homicide considered murder?

No, not all homicide is considered murder as it can be accidental or justifiable under certain circumstances. Murder involves the intentional killing of another person.

Q: How does the prosecution prove aggravation in a murder case?

The prosecution must provide evidence that shows certain factors, such as the murder being committed during the commission of a felony or the purpose of avoiding a lawful arrest, which make the murder more severe or aggravated.

Q: What is the significance of proving aggravation in this case?

Proving aggravation is necessary in order for the prosecution to seek the death penalty. It establishes that the murder is particularly heinous, atrocious, or cruel.

Q: Will the defense argue that the defendant, Donald Smith, has brain damage and impulse control problems?

Yes, it is expected that the defense will present testimony from doctors and experts who will claim that Donald Smith has brain damage and impulse control issues, potentially as an attempt to mitigate his actions.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• Homicide, the killing of one human being by another, is not always classified as murder and can be accidental or justifiable.

• In order to convict someone of first-degree murder, the prosecution must prove their guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

• The prosecution in this case is focusing on proving aggravation beyond a reasonable doubt in order to seek the death penalty.