December Reading Recommendations! Ideas & How They're Transmitted | Summary and Q&A

29.8K views
December 15, 2017
by
Philosophy Tube
YouTube video player
December Reading Recommendations! Ideas & How They're Transmitted

TL;DR

Oli reviews three books, including "Epistemology of Resistance," "Eclipse of Reason," and "Backlash," providing insights and recommendations for each.

Install to Summarize YouTube Videos and Get Transcripts

Key Insights

  • 🫵 Art can serve as a useful tool for conveying different points of view and improving communication.
  • 🍝 "Eclipse of Reason" explores subjective and objective reason, but its idealistic reconstructions of the past and its association of rationality with masculinity are limitations.

Transcript

hello everybody oli here it's time for another look at the last few books I've been reading and it'll give you a bit of a sneak peek as to what's coming up on the show - oh where shall I start I want to start with this one Jose Medina is the epistemology of resistance if you've been watching the show a while you might remember I did a video on 1984... Read More

Questions & Answers

Q: How does "Epistemology of Resistance" build on the ideas discussed in a previous video on knowledge?

"Epistemology of Resistance" serves as a follow-up to a previous video on knowledge, exploring how art can effectively convey different perspectives and improve communication. It criticizes a book called "Epistemic Injustice" and expands on the topic of who is allowed to have knowledge.

Q: What distinguishes subjective and objective reason in "Eclipse of Reason"?

The author of "Eclipse of Reason" makes a distinction between subjective reason, which guides individual choices, and objective reason, which shapes what individuals should desire. This distinction serves as a central theme in the book.

Q: What are some limitations of "Eclipse of Reason"?

While "Eclipse of Reason" offers interesting perspectives on subjective reason, it falls short when the author tries to reconstruct the past and present. He idealistically portrays the Enlightenment and ancient Greece, ignoring their societal contexts. Additionally, the book perpetuates gender stereotypes by associating rationality with masculinity.

Q: What does "Backlash" explore?

"Backlash" is a comprehensive examination of the times when women's rights have been rolled back and the anti-feminist responses they provoke. The book covers various periods, from ancient history to the Reagan era, providing historical context and case studies.

Summary & Key Takeaways

  • Oli reviews "Epistemology of Resistance," a follow-up to a previous video on knowledge, discussing how art can convey different points of view and the challenges of effective communication.

  • Oli discusses "Eclipse of Reason," highlighting its exploration of subjective and objective reason, but also expressing concerns about its idealistic reconstructions and limitations.

  • Oli highly recommends "Backlash," a book that examines the times when women's rights have been rolled back, providing historical context and detailed case studies.

Share This Summary 📚

Summarize YouTube Videos and Get Video Transcripts with 1-Click

Download browser extensions on:

Explore More Summaries from Philosophy Tube 📚

Summarize YouTube Videos and Get Video Transcripts with 1-Click

Download browser extensions on: