Books I LOVE, but CAN'T Ethically Recommend #2 | Trauma p*rn, homophobia, & bad mental illness rep | Summary and Q&A

TL;DR

The content discusses books that the creator enjoyed but cannot recommend due to ethical reasons, including issues with the authors or problematic content.

Key Insights

• 🎮 The video highlights the dilemma of enjoying books that have problematic elements and the ethical considerations behind recommending them.
• 💦 The creator emphasizes the importance of separating the author from their work and the personal choice to engage with books that may have problematic content.
• 🫵 It provides examples of popular books with controversial authors, such as Orson Scott Card, and discusses the impact of their views on readers' recommendations.
• 💦 The video encourages readers to consider diversity and inclusion in their book choices, prioritizing works by marginalized authors to support underrepresented voices.
• 🧑‍⚕️ It explores the complexities of navigating problematic content and delving into discussions around representation, mental health, and historical accuracy.
• 📔 The creator stresses the need to be critical readers and engage in conversations about ethical book recommendations, acknowledging the potential harm certain books can cause.

Transcript

this man needs to get off Twitter. what's up  y'all. today I am making a very special video   a video that I did not know that I'd be making  a follow-up to. toward the end of last year I   released a video where I discussed books that  I absolutely adored but could not recommend for   ethical reasons. and that video kind of blew up. I  really love... Read More

Questions & Answers

Q: Why does the creator discuss books they can't ethically recommend?

The creator wants to share books they enjoyed but also discuss the ethical reasons behind not being able to recommend them. It sparks conversation about the author-reader relationship and the need to consider ethical considerations in book recommendations.

Q: Can you provide an example of an author mentioned in the video?

Orson Scott Card, the author of Ender's Game, is discussed in the video due to his homophobic views. The creator explains that despite enjoying the book, they can't recommend it because they don't want to support the author.

Q: What are some of the problematic elements discussed in the video?

The video discusses issues such as racism, homophobia, sexual violence, and harmful depictions of mental illness. Each book is analyzed in terms of the ethical concerns the creator has regarding these elements.

Q: How does the creator approach the discussion of problematic books?

The creator acknowledges their personal response to the books while also recognizing the broader impact of problematic content. They emphasize the need to be mindful of the harm it can cause and the importance of finding alternative books by diverse authors.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• The video is a follow-up to a previous video where the creator discussed books they enjoyed but couldn't recommend ethically. They wanted to talk about more books in this video.

• The creator discusses books such as Ender's Game by Orson Scott Card, A Little Life by Hanya Yanagihara, Rage of Dragons by Evan Winter, Landline by Rainbow Rowell, Misery by Stephen King, and Shutter Island by Dennis Lehane.

• Each book is discussed in terms of what the creator loved about it and the reasons they can't ethically recommend it, such as problematic authors, harmful depictions, or offensive content.