Stacey Delikat & Legal Analyst Julie Rendelman Discuss Breaking News in Kellen Winslow Trial 6/11 | Summary and Q&A

TL;DR

The judge has declared a mistrial on the remaining charges against Kellen Winslow II, including rape, sodomy, and elder abuse, after the jury was deadlocked.

Key Insights

• 🧑‍⚖️ The defense's motion to dismiss the remaining charges was denied by the judge.
• 🥺 The jury's decision on a special allegation attached to one of the rape charges was confusing and led to the mistrial declaration.
• ❓ The mistrial does not affect the convictions already reached by the jury.
• 🧑‍⚖️ It is unclear if the prosecution will retry the case, and their decision may depend on the judge's determination during the sentencing phase.
• 🧑‍⚖️ The mistrial announcement was considered unusual, as the judge disclosed the split without specifying which counts were guilty or not guilty.
• 🎁 The mistrial does not impact the appeal process, which will focus on the legal arguments presented during the trial.
• 😉 The outcome of the mistrial can be seen as a win for the prosecution, as they were able to secure convictions on several serious charges.

Transcript

Read and summarize the transcript of this video on Glasp Reader (beta).

Questions & Answers

Q: Why did the judge deny the defense's motion to dismiss the remaining charges?

The judge denied the motion because of the confusion surrounding the jury's decision on a special allegation attached to one of the counts. He believed there was still a possibility the jury could reach a verdict on the remaining charges.

Q: What does the mistrial mean for the appeal?

The mistrial does not have a direct impact on the appeal process. The appeal will focus on the legal issues raised during the trial, not the outcome of the case.

Q: Will the prosecution retry the case?

It is uncertain whether the prosecution will retry the case. The decision may depend on the judge's determination during the sentencing phase and the seriousness of the charges that resulted in guilty verdicts.

Q: Is this a win or a loss for the prosecution?

This can be considered a win for the prosecution as they were able to secure convictions on some of the charges, guaranteeing serious jail time for Winslow. The mistrial does not negate the successful verdicts.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• The defense's motion to dismiss most of the remaining charges against Kellen Winslow II was denied by the judge.

• The jury found Winslow guilty of rape relating to Jane Doe number two, but their decision on a special allegation attached to the count was confusing and unclear.

• The judge declared a mistrial after the jury remained deadlocked on the remaining charges, and it is unclear if the prosecution will retry the case.