🚀 Is AI art ethical? Crossing the Canyon: Product Manager to Product Leader

Hatched by Kazuki
Aug 25, 2023
5 min read
0 views
Copy Link
🚀 Is AI art ethical? Crossing the Canyon: Product Manager to Product Leader
Artificial Intelligence (AI) has made significant strides in recent years, particularly in the field of art. However, the question of whether AI art is ethical has sparked heated debates among artists, critics, and enthusiasts alike. On one side of the argument, opponents claim that AI art lacks a soul and steals from "real" artists. On the other side, proponents argue that AI art democratizes access to art and expands the creative landscape. In this article, we will explore both perspectives and delve into the journey of a Product Manager (PM) crossing the canyon to become a Product Leader (PL).
The opponents of AI art argue that it is "soulless" because the AI system, such as DALL-E, generates images based on pre-existing data and algorithms. They contend that what makes art meaningful are the countless little decisions made by a human artist during the creative process. Emotions and motivations play a crucial role in imbuing art with depth and significance. As AI lacks these human qualities, opponents claim that AI-generated art cannot be considered true art.
Moreover, opponents argue that AI art steals from "real" artists. They contend that training AI models on millions of images of existing artwork is equivalent to copying or imitating the work of others. They raise concerns about the originality and authenticity of AI-generated art. However, a counter-argument suggests that inspiration and borrowing from other artists have always been prevalent in the art world. Even renowned artist Pablo Picasso famously stated, "good artists copy, great artists steal." This perspective highlights the blurred lines between inspiration, imitation, and theft in the creative process.
Proponents of AI art emphasize the democratization of access to art as a significant advantage. AI technology enables more people to engage in the creative process and express themselves artistically. By training AI models on vast datasets, AI art expands the possibilities for artistic expression and creativity. This accessibility fosters a more inclusive art community and empowers individuals who may not have had the opportunity to explore their artistic talents otherwise.
To address concerns about theft and authenticity, the concept of Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs) emerges as a potential solution. NFTs can be used to authenticate and establish ownership of digital art pieces. Each artwork published as an NFT would have a record of its original creator, making it difficult for others to claim ownership of identical pieces. This system provides a level of accountability and protection for artists, both human and AI-generated.
Transitioning from the discussion of AI art ethics, we shift our focus to the journey of a Product Manager (PM) becoming a Product Leader (PL). Not all product work is the same, and after achieving initial product-market fit, PMs face four distinct categories of product problems: feature work, growth work, scaling work, and product-market fit expansion. Each category requires a different approach and management strategy.
To become a successful PL, one must possess knowledge of all these product problem categories and guide their team to tackle the right problems at the right time. The role of a PL involves making decisions on prioritization and resource allocation to maximize the overall Return on Investment (ROI) between various types of product work. While an individual contributor at the Senior Product Manager (SPM) level focuses on maximizing the return of a specific type of work, a PL must navigate the bigger picture and optimize the collective output of their team.
Crucially, a PL must excel in influencing others within the organization. As a PM, the focus is primarily on solving problems directly within one's span of control. However, as a PL, the scope expands to identifying and addressing the broader set of obstacles blocking the problem area. This requires the ability to influence individuals outside of one's immediate function and problem area. Effective influencing involves convincing others to take action, even if they may not possess the same knowledge and understanding.
Successfully transitioning from a PM to a PL involves crossing the metaphorical canyon. One key aspect of this transition is learning how to create more scope and opportunities for the organization. While it is essential to empower the team and avoid making all decisions, escalating the right problems becomes paramount. Finding the balance between delegation and escalation ensures that the team grows and develops while crucial issues receive the necessary attention.
In conclusion, the question of whether AI art is ethical sparks debates surrounding the soullessness and alleged theft associated with AI-generated art. However, proponents argue that AI art democratizes access to creativity and expands the art community. Implementing NFTs can mitigate concerns about theft and establish ownership records. On a separate note, the journey from being a PM to a PL involves mastering the art of influencing and optimizing the collective output of the team. To successfully navigate this transition, creating scope and opportunities for the organization becomes crucial.
Actionable Advice:
- 1. Embrace the possibilities of AI art while acknowledging the importance of human emotions and motivations in the creative process. Explore the unique qualities that both AI and human artists bring to the table.
- 2. Consider the potential of NFTs to protect the authenticity and ownership of digital art, regardless of whether it is created by AI or humans. Explore the emerging opportunities and challenges of this technology.
- 3. As a PM aspiring to become a PL, focus on developing your influencing skills. Learn how to effectively communicate and convince others, even outside your immediate domain, to take action and drive positive change.
Resource:
Copy Link