Understanding Federal Forfeiture and Real Rights
Hatched by Diego Ospina Serna
Sep 27, 2023
4 min read
1 views
Copy Link
Understanding Federal Forfeiture and Real Rights
Introduction:
Federal forfeiture is a legal process that aims to seize assets used in illegal activities by criminal organizations. Inspired by American legislation on asset forfeiture, the concept of "extinción de dominio" (extinction of domain) has been implemented in various countries. This article will explore the different types of federal forfeiture, including criminal, civil judicial, and administrative forfeiture. Additionally, we will delve into the concept of real rights, focusing on the classification of subjective rights and the distinction between real rights and rights of credit.
Types of Federal Forfeiture:
1. Criminal Forfeiture (Decomiso Penal):
Criminal forfeiture is an in personam action that occurs within a criminal process. It requires a criminal conviction and is part of the defendant's sentence. The forfeiture is limited to the property interests of the defendant, including any proceeds obtained through illegal activities. It is typically restricted to the property involved in the specific counts on which the defendant is convicted. A separate ancillary proceeding is initiated to determine any third-party ownership interests in the property subject to forfeiture.
2. Civil Judicial Forfeiture (Decomiso Civil):
Civil judicial forfeiture is an in rem court proceeding brought against property derived from or used to commit an offense, rather than against the person who committed the offense. Unlike criminal forfeiture, it does not require a criminal conviction. However, the government must prove in court that the property is linked to criminal activity. This type of forfeiture allows the court to address all issues related to the property and gather all parties with an interest in the property in a single case. It enables the government to target assets that may not be reachable through criminal forfeiture, such as those held by criminals located outside the United States or deceased defendants.
3. Administrative Forfeiture (Decomiso Administrativo):
Administrative forfeiture is an in rem action that allows property to be forfeited to the United States without filing a case in federal court. It occurs when no one contests the seizure and is carried out by the agency that seized the assets. Strict procedures, including time limits and noticing requirements, are in place to protect the rights of property holders. Administrative forfeiture requires probable cause for the seizure of property. It is a beneficial process to avoid burdening the courts with judicial actions when there is no contestation of the seizure.
Understanding Real Rights:
Real rights are a category of subjective rights that directly pertain to things or property. The concept of real rights dates back to Roman law, where a distinction was made between real rights and rights of credit. Real rights, known as "jus in re," directly apply to things and establish a direct relationship between the holder of the right and the object of the right. In contrast, rights of credit involve a relationship between a creditor and a debtor, with the creditor having a right to claim the fulfillment of an obligation.
Classification of Subjective Rights:
Subjective rights can be classified into three main groups: rights of personality, family rights, and patrimonial rights. Rights of personality are inherent to every individual by virtue of their existence. Family rights arise from kinship relationships. Patrimonial rights have an economic content and encompass rights of credit and real rights.
Conclusion:
Federal forfeiture encompasses various types, including criminal, civil judicial, and administrative forfeiture. Each type has its own characteristics and purposes but ultimately serves the objective of depriving criminals of the assets used in illegal activities. Understanding real rights helps us distinguish between the different categories of subjective rights and highlights the direct relationship between the holder and the object of a real right. By comprehending these concepts, individuals can navigate the complex legal landscape surrounding federal forfeiture and real rights.
Actionable Advice:
- 1. Stay informed about the specific laws and regulations regarding federal forfeiture in your jurisdiction to understand your rights and responsibilities.
- 2. If you suspect your property may be subject to forfeiture, seek legal counsel immediately to protect your interests and explore possible defenses.
- 3. Educate yourself on the difference between real rights and rights of credit to understand the nature of your legal relationship with your assets and obligations.
Resource:
Copy Link