The Top 10 Mistakes Authors Make in Writing Alternate History
Hatched by Diego Ospina Serna
Nov 08, 2023
5 min read
5 views
Copy Link
The Top 10 Mistakes Authors Make in Writing Alternate History
Introduction:
Alternate history is a fascinating genre that allows authors to explore the possibilities of what could have been if certain events in history had taken a different turn. However, like any genre, there are common pitfalls that authors often fall into when crafting their alternate worlds. In this article, we will explore the top 10 mistakes that authors make in writing alternate history and provide actionable advice on how to avoid them.
1. Focusing too much on one changed event:
One of the most common mistakes authors make in alternate history is concentrating too much on the one changed event, rather than considering all the events that led up to it. In order to create a coherent and believable alternate universe, it is essential to understand the historical context and the factors that influenced the course of events. By neglecting the broader historical framework, authors risk creating a narrative that lacks depth and coherence.
2. Failing to bring the alternate history up to the present:
While the past may be another country, an alternate history is a whole new world. The best alternate histories are those that not only offer a fresh perspective on the past but also bring the altered timeline up to the reader's present. By doing so, authors can explore the consequences of their changes and create a rich and immersive reading experience.
3. Ignoring the inevitability of certain historical developments:
It is important for authors to recognize that some historical developments were likely inevitable, even in an alternate timeline. Changing one major event may have far-reaching consequences, but it is crucial to consider the ripple effects and the underlying factors that shaped history. By understanding the inevitability of certain developments, authors can create a more believable and nuanced alternate history.
4. Neglecting important historical factors:
In crafting an alternate history, authors must make informed decisions about which historical points to pursue and which to let go. However, it is essential to give due consideration to the factors that were important at the time, even if they may not be immediately critical to the story. By taking a more holistic approach to alternate timeline building, authors can create a more authentic and immersive reading experience.
5. Failing to account for the ripples of one big change:
In alternate history, one major change can have far-reaching consequences. However, authors must also consider the ripples that result from those initial changes. Just as ripples have ripples, authors cannot account for all the potential consequences of a single point of departure. Nonetheless, it is important to pay attention to events that almost happened in real history, as they may have occurred if circumstances were different.
6. Mixing up urban legends with actual history:
As authors, it is crucial to separate fact from fiction when writing alternate history. People often assume they know things about the past that are actually folk-history and incorrect. By thoroughly researching and fact-checking historical details, authors can avoid falling into the trap of perpetuating false information.
7. Assuming that nothing will change or that everything will change:
In crafting alternate history, authors must strike a balance between realism and creativity. Pretending that absolutely nothing will change apart from one historical event is as unrealistic as assuming that the world will be entirely different in every detail. Authors must carefully consider the implications of their changes and create a believable alternate world that remains grounded in historical plausibility.
8. Making the story go where you want it to go, instead of where your altered history will support:
While authors have creative freedom in crafting their stories, it is essential to ensure that the narrative aligns with the changes made in the alternate history. Straying too far from the plausibility of the altered timeline can undermine the reader's suspension of disbelief and detract from the overall coherence of the story.
9. Explaining too much:
While research is crucial in writing alternate history, authors must be cautious not to overwhelm readers with excessive detail. The 'As you know, Bob' syndrome, where authors feel the need to explain every historical nuance, can bog down the narrative and detract from the storytelling. It is important to strike a balance between providing enough context for readers to understand the alternate history while keeping the focus on the characters and their story.
10. Forgetting to tell a good story:
Ultimately, the success of an alternate history lies in the ability to tell a compelling and engaging story. While exploring the 'what if' question is fascinating, it is equally important to create interesting characters and a narrative worth telling. By focusing on character development and creating a timeless story, authors can ensure that their alternate history resonates with readers.
Actionable Advice:
- 1. Research extensively: Take the time to thoroughly research the historical period you are altering and be mindful of the details that will shape your alternate timeline.
- 2. Create a holistic narrative: Consider the broader historical context and how your changes will impact the world beyond the initial altered event.
- 3. Focus on character development: Remember that at the heart of any story, even alternate history, lie relatable characters with motivations and emotions that resonate with readers.
Conclusion:
Writing alternate history is a thrilling endeavor that allows authors to explore the endless possibilities of what could have been. By avoiding the common mistakes discussed in this article and following the actionable advice provided, authors can create compelling and immersive alternate worlds that captivate readers. Remember, the key to a great alternate history lies in striking a balance between historical plausibility and a captivating story.
Resource:
Copy Link