The Art of Disagreement and the Power of Critical Thinking

Alessio Frateily

Hatched by Alessio Frateily

Sep 18, 2023

4 min read


The Art of Disagreement and the Power of Critical Thinking


In a world where disagreement is rampant and critical thinking skills are often lacking, it is crucial to explore how we can disagree effectively and improve our ability to think critically. This article delves into the different stages of disagreement and provides insights into the importance of solitude and dedicated thinking time. By combining these two areas, we can enhance our communication skills and make better decisions.

The Art of Disagreement:

Disagreement is a natural response to ideas and opinions that differ from our own. However, simply attacking the author or their tone is a weak form of disagreement. What truly matters is whether the author is right or wrong, rather than their tone. It is essential to explore uncharted territory and provide a well-reasoned refutation when we disagree. By doing so, we can elevate the conversation and promote a deeper understanding of the topic at hand.

Understanding the Stages of Disagreement:

To effectively disagree, it is helpful to categorize the different stages of disagreement. These stages include:

  • 1. Name-calling: This is the lowest form of disagreement, where individuals resort to insults and derogatory language. It adds no value to the conversation and should be avoided.
  • 2. Ad Hominem: An ad hominem attack focuses on attacking the character or authority of the author rather than addressing the argument itself. While it may carry some weight, it is important to separate personal attacks from the validity of the argument.
  • 3. Responding to Tone: Disagreeing with the author's tone is a weak form of disagreement. It is crucial to focus on the content rather than the delivery. A flippant author may still be correct, and a grave author may be wrong. Pointing out errors or providing evidence is more effective in challenging the argument.
  • 4. Contradiction: Contradiction involves stating the opposing case with little or no supporting evidence. While this can sometimes shed light on a different perspective, it is essential to provide evidence and reasoning to make a convincing argument.
  • 5. Counterargument: Counterargument is the first form of convincing disagreement. It involves providing reasoning and evidence to contradict the original argument directly. When done effectively, counterarguments can challenge and enhance the conversation.
  • 6. Refuting the Central Point: This is the highest form of disagreement. It involves refuting the central point of the argument by presenting compelling evidence and reasoning. By addressing the core of the argument, individuals can engage in meaningful and thought-provoking discussions.

The Power of Critical Thinking:

Critical thinking is a skill that is often overlooked but is crucial for making better decisions and solving problems effectively. It requires the ability to think through complex issues, consider various perspectives, and come up with original ideas. However, in today's fast-paced world of multitasking, true critical thinking is often hindered.

Multitasking and its Impact on Thinking:

Contrary to popular belief, multitasking does not enhance cognitive abilities. Studies have shown that the more people multitask, the worse they perform in various mental tasks. Multitasking impairs the ability to distinguish between relevant and irrelevant information, retrieve information quickly, and maintain mental organization. It hampers the very essence of thinking, as it prevents individuals from concentrating on a single idea and developing it fully.

The Importance of Solitude and Concentration:

To truly enhance critical thinking, it is imperative to prioritize solitude and concentration. By immersing ourselves in a problem and dedicating uninterrupted time to think, we can gain insights that would otherwise be missed. Slowing down, concentrating, and patiently allowing all parts of our mind to come into play enables us to develop original ideas and make connections that lead to better decision-making.

The Role of Writing in Thinking:

Writing is a powerful tool that enhances thinking. It forces us to slow down, articulate our thoughts clearly, and develop coherent arguments. Good writing requires good thinking, and the act of writing itself helps clarify our ideas. As Leslie Lamport said, "If you're thinking without writing, you only think you're thinking." Writing provides a platform for our minds to make associations, draw connections, and surprise us with new insights.

Actionable Advice:

  • 1. Embrace solitude: Carve out dedicated time for deep thinking and reflection. Disconnect from distractions and allow your mind to focus on the problem at hand.
  • 2. Practice active listening: When engaging in a disagreement, actively listen to the opposing argument and seek to understand it fully before formulating your response. This promotes a more constructive and meaningful conversation.
  • 3. Write regularly: Develop a habit of writing to enhance your thinking skills. Whether it's journaling, blogging, or writing essays, the act of writing helps clarify your thoughts and develop original ideas.


In a world filled with disagreement and a lack of critical thinking, it is crucial to learn how to disagree effectively and enhance our thinking skills. By understanding the different stages of disagreement and prioritizing solitude and concentration, we can engage in more meaningful conversations and make better decisions. Embracing the power of critical thinking and dedicating time for deep thinking will ultimately lead to personal growth and a more thoughtful approach to life's challenges.

Hatch New Ideas with Glasp AI 🐣

Glasp AI allows you to hatch new ideas based on your curated content. Let's curate and create with Glasp AI :)