The Complex Influences on Belief Formation and Historical Engagement

Aviral Vaid

Aviral Vaid

Jul 19, 20234 min read


The Complex Influences on Belief Formation and Historical Engagement


Understanding why we believe the things we do and how we engage with history is crucial for uncovering the complexity of human behavior. Our beliefs are not solely based on truth, but are influenced by various factors such as personal desires, the need for certainty, and the preservation of reputation. Similarly, engaging with history allows us to gain insights into human behavior patterns and make accurate predictions for the future. In this article, we will explore the connections between belief formation and historical engagement, highlighting the inherent biases and challenges we face in these processes.

Belief Formation: The Influence of Desires and Uncertainty

Our beliefs are shaped by how much we want them to be true. The more a belief helps us cope with uncertainty, the easier it is for us to embrace it. This innate tendency stems from our need for stability and our capacity to believe in ideas that are advantageous to us, rather than those aligned with truth. Moreover, beliefs often serve purposes beyond discovering what is true. They can justify our past actions, protect our reputation, provide hope, maximize income, or signal our affiliation to a particular group. This demonstrates that our beliefs are not solely guided by evidence or rational thinking.

Selective Memory and Cherry-Picked Evidence

Memories of past events are not objective records but instead are filtered through our subjective lens. We tend to retain information that makes sense to us and discard confusing details. This selective memory process can lead to the formation of beliefs based on biased experiences that appear evidence-based. In a complex world, where information overload is common, we instinctively cherry-pick evidence that aligns with our preconceived notions. This tendency stems from our inclination towards simplified narratives, which can result in self-deception and the acceptance of falsehoods over admitting mistakes.

The Challenge of Changing Beliefs

Changing our beliefs is often a challenging endeavor. It can feel as if all the effort we put into establishing our previous beliefs was wasted. Additionally, when we shift from one belief to another, there is a tendency to doubt the new belief's validity, especially in the eyes of others. This fear of being seen as fickle or inconsistent can hinder our willingness to change our minds, leading us to cling onto false beliefs. The desire to eliminate uncertainty, rather than seeking truth, further complicates the process of belief transformation.

Engaging with History: Uncovering Patterns and Forecasting the Future

To truly understand human behavior, it is essential to engage with history. By studying historical events, we gain insights into recurrent patterns that have shaped our societies. The more we observe a behavior throughout history, the more confident we become in predicting its influence on our future. For instance, economic collapses driven by excessive debt and optimistic market sentiments have occurred repeatedly throughout history. Recognizing these patterns enhances our ability to forecast accurately and make informed decisions.

Connecting Belief Formation and Historical Engagement

Belief formation and historical engagement are interconnected processes. Engaging with history allows us to challenge our existing beliefs and recognize their limitations. It provides a broader perspective, highlighting the prevalence of certain behaviors and shaping our understanding of human nature. By acknowledging the biases and limitations in our belief formation, we can approach historical engagement with a more open mind and critically analyze the patterns and trends that have influenced our beliefs.

Actionable Advice:

  • 1. Embrace uncertainty: Recognize that the elimination of uncertainty is not equivalent to finding truth. Embrace the discomfort that comes with uncertainty and be open to challenging your beliefs when new evidence arises.
  • 2. Seek diverse perspectives: Engage with a variety of viewpoints and actively seek out perspectives that challenge your existing beliefs. This will help you develop a more comprehensive understanding of complex issues and reduce the risk of falling into confirmation bias.
  • 3. Emphasize evidence-based thinking: When forming beliefs or engaging with historical events, prioritize evidence-based thinking over personal desires or preconceived notions. Strive to make rational decisions by critically evaluating the available information.


Understanding why we believe the things we do and how we engage with history requires a deep examination of our biases, desires, and the complexities of human behavior. By recognizing the influence of personal desires on belief formation and the importance of engaging with history, we can navigate the challenges of forming accurate beliefs and making informed decisions. Embracing uncertainty, seeking diverse perspectives, and emphasizing evidence-based thinking are actionable steps towards honing our critical thinking skills and cultivating a more nuanced understanding of the world around us.

Want to hatch new ideas?

Glasp AI allows you to hatch new ideas based on your curated content. Let's curate and create with Glasp AI :)