The Changing Landscape: From Economic Liberalism to Relativism in Russia

Lucas Charbonnier

Lucas Charbonnier

Sep 20, 20234 min read


The Changing Landscape: From Economic Liberalism to Relativism in Russia

In recent years, the actions of Russia's central bank have sparked controversy and raised questions about the country's economic direction. Under the leadership of Elvira Nabiullina, the bank has implemented measures that have further isolated Russia from global trade flows, surpassing the effects of international sanctions. These policies have included restricting money transfers abroad and compelling Russian businesses to convert 80% of their foreign currency earnings into rubles. Additionally, Nabiullina has capped withdrawals from foreign currency bank accounts, angering many Russians who had long relied on dollars or euros for their savings. The central bank claims that only the wealthiest individuals are affected by this measure, as 90% of bank deposits are too small to be impacted. This shift in policy marks a departure from years of economic liberalism, replacing it with a more interventionist and controlling approach.

The central bank's change in direction has surprised many, as it had previously made efforts to integrate Russia into the global economy. For years, the bank had worked towards this goal, with Nabiullina overseeing the transition of the ruble into a floating currency in 2014. However, on February 24th, everything seemed to change. This abrupt policy shift has left many questioning the motives behind Nabiullina's actions. Unfortunately, the central bank has declined to make Nabiullina available for an interview, citing her busy schedule.

One can't help but wonder if these policies are a sacrifice of everything Nabiullina had built in her career as the central bank governor. While the motivations behind these decisions remain unclear, it is essential to explore the broader implications of such actions. By erecting barriers to international trade and implementing stringent controls on currency movements, Russia risks further isolating itself from the global economy. This isolation can have severe consequences for the country's economic growth and development.

The question of whether "to each their truth" is a principle of tolerance is also relevant in this context. It is tempting to argue that truth is relative and subjective, dependent on individual perspectives. This notion is often employed as a defense against those who seek to impose their truths on others. However, the relativism of truth has its limits. If we accept that all opinions are equal without any criteria to evaluate them, the very concept of truth becomes diluted. This extreme relativism can lead to skepticism and a lack of intellectual progress.

Language itself provides evidence that truth is not entirely relative. Words can be used to denote various objects, implying a shared essence between them. For instance, the word "tree" encompasses all objects defined as such, irrespective of individual perceptions of their size or beauty. Plato's allegory of the cave in "The Republic" illustrates this idea, highlighting the realm of appearance and opinion versus the pursuit of truth.

In our search for truth, it is imperative to recognize that it is not easily grasped. It requires diligent research and the willingness to challenge our own beliefs and biases. Scientists, philosophers, investigators, and judges all engage in this pursuit, constantly aware of the potential subjectivity of their perspectives. Protocols and methodologies help us move from subjective opinions to objective knowledge. However, acknowledging the existence of absolute truth does not negate the relative nature of scientific progress. The methods employed to uncover absolute truth are always rooted in history and open to debate.

In conclusion, the decisions made by Russia's central bank under the leadership of Elvira Nabiullina have raised concerns about the country's economic direction. The implementation of policies that restrict international trade and control currency movements risks isolating Russia further from the global economy. Simultaneously, the question of relativism in truth challenges our understanding of knowledge and the limits of tolerance. While it is essential to consider multiple perspectives, it is also crucial to recognize the existence of absolute truths that can guide our pursuit of progress.

Actionable Advice:

1. Stay informed about global economic developments and their potential impact on your country or region. Understanding the policies implemented by central banks and their implications can help you make informed decisions.

2. Diversify your assets and investments. In uncertain economic times, it is crucial to have a balanced portfolio that can withstand potential fluctuations. Consider investing in different currencies and markets to mitigate risks.

3. Engage in critical thinking and research. Don't take information at face value; instead, question, analyze, and seek multiple perspectives. This approach will help you navigate complex issues and make well-informed decisions.

Want to hatch new ideas?

Glasp AI allows you to hatch new ideas based on your curated content. Let's curate and create with Glasp AI :)